You forgot Antonio Banderas. He belongs in both groups.I guess there are some actors that I think are nice looking, although I would not extend it to a crush by any stretch of the imagination. I just think they are esthetically pleasing.
The List of "Unconventional" Good Looking Actors: Adam Driver, Adrien Brody, Dev Patel, Jeff Goldblum, Benicio del Toro, Jake Johnson, Oh Ji-ho, Llorenç González, and Domhnall Gleeson. Domhnall Gleeson is the outlier here because I typically prefer dark hair.
The List of (More) "Conventional" Good Looking Actors: Gregory Peck, Ben Barns, Cillian Murphy, Sendhil Ramamurthy, and Yon González.