Is the Instinct food all pate? Only reason I ask is I tried the duck tonight and it was a fail for two of my three kittens and only a so-so for the third... the two old cats love it... just like all canned LOLAs confirmed by Instinct this morning, they have tweaked the formula and the chicken cat and dog are now the same. Cans with a Use By date of 3/15/18 or later is the newer formula. I hope this helps to clarify.