Dec 24, 2021 #1 AbbysMom At Abby's beck and call Thread starter Staff Member Moderator Joined May 18, 2005 Messages 78,765 Purraise 20,052 Location Massachusetts I'm going with chocolate.
Dec 24, 2021 #2 sivyaleah TCS Member Veteran Joined Dec 16, 2011 Messages 6,272 Purraise 5,250 Location New Jersey Key Lime please.
Dec 24, 2021 #3 Katie M TCS Member Top Cat Joined Jun 1, 2017 Messages 5,069 Purraise 19,537 Location Kingwood, WV Key lime!
Dec 24, 2021 #5 goingpostal TCS Member Super Cat Joined Mar 11, 2011 Messages 858 Purraise 1,231 Location MN Chocolate! My mom usually makes several and the french silk is my first pick.
Dec 24, 2021 #6 muffy TCS Member Top Cat Joined Aug 9, 2014 Messages 6,198 Purraise 12,664 Location Fredericksburg, VA Peach
Dec 24, 2021 #7 Kat0121 TCS Member Veteran Joined Feb 23, 2014 Messages 15,068 Purraise 20,420 Location Sunny Florida Key lime as long as that is whipped cream on top and not meringue.
Dec 24, 2021 #8 rubysmama Forum Helper Staff Member Forum Helper Joined Nov 25, 2013 Messages 25,609 Purraise 64,180 Location Canada No lemon meringue. Or apple. So I'd have to settle for one of the other fruit ones.
Dec 24, 2021 #9 neely May the purr be with you Veteran Joined Dec 22, 2005 Messages 20,027 Purraise 48,857 Pumpkin especially if it's lightly warm up.
Dec 24, 2021 #10 Margot Lane Kitten at heart, not a Top Cat Top Cat Joined Oct 24, 2021 Messages 4,557 Purraise 9,458 Can’t choose! Shoot me!
Dec 24, 2021 #11 V verna davies TCS Member Veteran Joined Feb 23, 2016 Messages 23,639 Purraise 17,513 Location Wales uk Cherry every time.
Dec 24, 2021 #12 MonaLyssa33 TCS Member Top Cat Joined Mar 10, 2018 Messages 3,623 Purraise 9,584 Location Minneapolis Chocolate
Dec 24, 2021 #13 strider rose cat toy lady and cat mom to 3 Top Cat Joined Jul 19, 2020 Messages 10,105 Purraise 17,900 Location Marshall Michigan pecan for me , but i cant choose cause they all look so good
Dec 24, 2021 #14 TMcats TCS Member Alpha Cat Joined Mar 25, 2021 Messages 605 Purraise 243 Location The best place in BC Always pumpkin!
Dec 24, 2021 #15 Margot Lane Kitten at heart, not a Top Cat Top Cat Joined Oct 24, 2021 Messages 4,557 Purraise 9,458 strider rose said: pecan for me , but i cant choose cause they all look so good Click to expand... But is that ‘peek an’ or ‘peekan?’ I’m told it makes the taste different. Especially if it has whiskey.
strider rose said: pecan for me , but i cant choose cause they all look so good Click to expand... But is that ‘peek an’ or ‘peekan?’ I’m told it makes the taste different. Especially if it has whiskey.
Dec 24, 2021 #16 Margot Lane Kitten at heart, not a Top Cat Top Cat Joined Oct 24, 2021 Messages 4,557 Purraise 9,458 OK I don’t know how you guys are deciding. What about huckleberry and banana cream? Plus the crust is so vital, esp w/ apple.
OK I don’t know how you guys are deciding. What about huckleberry and banana cream? Plus the crust is so vital, esp w/ apple.
Dec 24, 2021 #17 V vince TCS Member Top Cat Joined Jul 23, 2017 Messages 2,172 Purraise 3,540 Location metro Detroit Peach.
Dec 24, 2021 #18 susanm9006 Lola Top Cat Joined Feb 20, 2011 Messages 13,379 Purraise 30,896 Location Minnesota Cherry and pumpkin.
Dec 24, 2021 #19 Maria Bayote Mama of 4 Cats, 4 Dogs , 2 Budgies & 2 Humans Top Cat Joined Jan 15, 2018 Messages 4,170 Purraise 12,685 Pistachio.
Dec 24, 2021 #20 MoochNNoodles TCS Member Veteran Joined Apr 30, 2005 Messages 36,820 Purraise 23,935 Location Where my cats are Cherry! Kind of wishing for that instead of the apple and pumpkin i made for Christmas!