Sadly cats would rather starve than eat something they do not like. They are not dogs that will eventually eat when they get hungry enough and in some cases wolf down the food in one sitting. You have not lost your marbles. Like I said Mojo right now eats everything however when he gets older he may get more fussy about his food. Mojo was a shelter baby so I guess he is happy to be spoiled right now. It's good you're trying wet food over dry.Lucky you. My husband thinks I've lost my marbles for obsessing about his eating. He thinks I should just leave him be "he'll eat when he gets hungry". I can't do that. I want to see what he likes & fill his cabinet