- Thread Starter Thread Starter
- #21
I gave up on First Mate. Their quality is inconsistent. I also gave up on Tikicat since the only ones I could ever find all had fish. Feeding too much fish is not good for cats. I now feed all of my cats commercial raw food. No vomiting for past few years and odorless stools. It is interesting that even First Mates canned fish food is ALSO inconsistent and just makes the case of their food quality worse.