American Idol Discussion Thread Feb 20

[sofiecusion]

Will any of you vote tonight?

 

[pami]

I have never ever voted before.

 

[snosrap5]

Oh man, Phil was very good !!!!


Why would Ryan push Simon's buttons!!! Why?

 

[pami]

Originally Posted by snosrap5

Oh man, Phil was very good !!!!


Why would Ryan push Simon's buttons!!! Why?

Doesnt Simon produce the show? I would think Ryan would at least show respect.

 

[gemlady]

I've caught bits and pieces and have these comments.

Originally Posted by Moz

Those are my favourites (although Chris Sligh--Jack Osbourne lookalike) too!

Originally Posted by sofiecusion

LOL at him making fun of Simon and almost leaving him speechless!!!!

I heard Chris when they played his bit from Hell Week during the final selections program and I liked what I heard. I liked him a lot more than Mr. Pedro who was too breathy IMO. Simon's comments about about both confirms my opinions of Simon. He has a tin ear.

Originally Posted by Pami

hes not wearing shoes because it brought him luck so he said he will never do another performance with his shoes on ...............

2 thumbs down for him ......

I recall he said he also has a pair of lucky underwear.

 

[snosrap5]

Originally Posted by sofiecusion

Will any of you vote tonight?

I never vote this early in the competition. I rarely vote at the end either. I just enjoy watching!

 

[babyharley]

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

Blake has been the best so far!

He is my favorite, he's got a great voice, and he's reallly easy on the eyes

I hope he goes far!

 

[katiemae1277]

well I just finished watching it and have to say that I was not really impressed by anyone, but I did *like* the beatboxer's performance, that's Blake, right? I also really liked Chris Sligh, his voice sounded the best, the most rich? I want to say? to me, AJ was pretty good too and I can't believe that Sanjaya attempted my Elliott's song!!!

boo hiss!! and Phil was pretty good, but that was my wedding song, and I'm just not too fond of that song anymore

very disappointed tonight

hopefully the girls will be much better!

 

[alaynna]

Originally Posted by Pami

Doesnt Simon produce the show? I would think Ryan would at least show respect.

It's all an act

....They are actually good friends outside of the show.

 

[halfpint]

I didn't think anyone was all that good at all. I wouldn't vote now anyway I usually don't even watch it till it's down to the last few weeks ..