AI Discussion Time again..SPOILERS INSIDE.. Thursday Feb 22

[neetanddave]

No way that kid was in the top 4 guys.

I think votefortheworst is at work....

 

[snosrap5]

Paula is so weird!!! She is repeating her words like she's a stuttering

 

[markvg]

Originally Posted by Pami

Well maybe one day he will agree to it and we can see his judgeship

Yes, we have an agreement. However, when it comes to the finals I could photoshop something with me but Neet will have to do something really bad to break the agreement.

Poke Neet with a stick enough times and you never know.

 

[clixpix]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

I think people vote off the ones he likes cause they hate him. But I bet if you look back, he has been behind ALL the past winners. He is a good judge of talent, he just doesn't pull any punches. Which I can relate too.

Actually I think people agree with Simon more than you think. I know I do. All I hear from Randy is "pitchy" "you worked it out" and "dawg". Paula doesn't want to hurt anyone's feelings, so she's generally soft with them. Simon is harsh for sure, but at least he's actually judging them, and is coherent. I think Simon generally knows how to work the TV audience to get them to vote the way he wants. Sometimes he gets blindsided, but mostly he gets what he wants. I don't know what happened last year, though, because Simon sure didn't want Taylor Hicks to win. I think people just really liked that quirky charm he had, and it overrode what Simon wanted...for the first time.

 

[snosrap5]

Originally Posted by clixpix

Actually I think people agree with Simon more than you think. I know I do. All I hear from Randy is "pitchy" "you worked it out" and "dawg". Paula doesn't want to hurt anyone's feelings, so she's generally soft with them. Simon is harsh for sure, but at least he's actually judging them, and is coherent. I think Simon generally knows how to work the TV audience to get them to vote the way he wants. Sometimes he gets blindsided, but mostly he gets what he wants. I don't know what happened last year, though, because Simon sure didn't want Taylor Hicks to win. I think people just really liked that quirky charm he had, and it overrode what Simon wanted...for the first time.

I couldn't have said it better myself. Exactly what I think!

 

[neetanddave]

Originally Posted by clixpix

Actually I think people agree with Simon more than you think. I know I do. All I hear from Randy is "pitchy" "you worked it out" and "dawg". Paula doesn't want to hurt anyone's feelings, so she's generally soft with them. Simon is harsh for sure, but at least he's actually judging them, and is coherent. I think Simon generally knows how to work the TV audience to get them to vote the way he wants. Sometimes he gets blindsided, but mostly he gets what he wants. I don't know what happened last year, though, because Simon sure didn't want Taylor Hicks to win. I think people just really liked that quirky charm he had, and it overrode what Simon wanted...for the first time.

Hey, I agreed with Simon last year too. I really really don't like Taylor.

 

[markvg]

Originally Posted by clixpix

Actually I think people agree with Simon more than you think. I know I do. All I hear from Randy is "pitchy" "you worked it out" and "dawg". Paula doesn't want to hurt anyone's feelings, so she's generally soft with them. Simon is harsh for sure, but at least he's actually judging them, and is coherent. I think Simon generally knows how to work the TV audience to get them to vote the way he wants. Sometimes he gets blindsided, but mostly he gets what he wants. I don't know what happened last year, though, because Simon sure didn't want Taylor Hicks to win. I think people just really liked that quirky charm he had, and it overrode what Simon wanted...for the first time.

I haven't watched the show too much but I agree. Simon does judge them. Paula is pretty much useless. Randy is kind of a buffer between Simon and clueless Paula. That's just my opinion.

 

[neetanddave]

Originally Posted by markvg

Yes, we have an agreement. However, when it comes to the finals I could photoshop something with me but Neet will have to do something really bad to break the agreement.

Poke Neet with a stick enough times and you never know.

I heard that.... and I know what your Indian name is, remember????

 

[markvg]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

I heard that.... and I know what your Indian name is, remember????

Yes, I remember, and I like the name!

 

[lokismum]

Missed this tonight! I was watching Survivor and flipping to American Idol during the commercials! This sucks having both of them on at the same time!

 

[clixpix]

Originally Posted by LokisMum

Missed this tonight! I was watching Survivor and flipping to American Idol during the commercials! This sucks having both of them on at the same time!

And that is why God invented DVRs!

For me, I wouldn't be able to choose between Idol and Lost.

 

[lsulover]

Originally Posted by Pami

I wonder where Belinda and Mark are. .............. Helen is in Florida.

I posted on another thread that I was gonna miss it tonight. We had a workshop to go to for work.

 

[lsulover]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

Jimmy is home from offshore, they may be out and about.

Yeah, we need Judge Mark!

Nope, Jimmy is at work, he left Tuesday night.

 

[lsulover]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

Sundance is gonna be this year's sleeper.

I think so too, I like Sundance

 

[lsulover]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

He might, but I won't. We ain't posting pics of each other. And the only other person here that has any of us is Belinda, and we all know how good she is at the posting pics thing...

I learned how to post them pictures, remember, and I think I might remember, if I don't I have other friends here who would be willing to help me.

 

[lsulover]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

I heard that.... and I know what your Indian name is, remember????

I don't remember it I don't think, I don't know, maybe I do, I am so confused.

 

[neetanddave]

Originally Posted by LSULOVER

I learned how to post them pictures, remember, and I think I might remember, if I don't I have other friends here who would be willing to help me.

Well, I guess I REALLY need to try and be nicer to you now.

Originally Posted by LSULOVER

I don't remember it I don't think, I don't know, maybe I do, I am so confused

We were just talking about it Wednesday night in the AI thread.

"He who pokes with a big stick"

 

[lsulover]

Originally Posted by neetanddave

Well, I guess I REALLY need to try and be nicer to you now.

We were just talking about it Wednesday night in the AI thread.

"He who pokes with a big stick"

I remember that name, but I didn't remember that it was Mark's name.

And yes you probably do need to be nicer to me, I have some pictures of you too.

 

[AbbysMom]

Originally Posted by clixpix

But she sang the heck out of that song, though! I just always want good things for Fantasia.

Although I agree the dress wasn't the best choice, she did great singing that song. I hope she does well on Broadway.

Originally Posted by clixpix

I think he thought he had sunk Gina Glockson. I think he wants her around for a bit more, and he was catty with her last night.

I was thinking the same thing.

Originally Posted by clixpix

Actually I think people agree with Simon more than you think. I know I do. All I hear from Randy is "pitchy" "you worked it out" and "dawg". Paula doesn't want to hurt anyone's feelings, so she's generally soft with them. Simon is harsh for sure, but at least he's actually judging them, and is coherent. I think Simon generally knows how to work the TV audience to get them to vote the way he wants. Sometimes he gets blindsided, but mostly he gets what he wants. I don't know what happened last year, though, because Simon sure didn't want Taylor Hicks to win. I think people just really liked that quirky charm he had, and it overrode what Simon wanted...for the first time.

Simon is right on most of the time although he can be harsh with his delivery. He does need to be a bit easier on people during the tryouts though. The "bush baby" comment still bothers me.

The group song last night was excruciating, and so was having to hear those four sing again. I didn't agree with who got the boot, but next week is another week.

Interesting that Chris Daughtry's song is the new goodbye song and is also being used in promos.

 

[neetanddave]

not such good news on Jersey today.... if it's true....

http://www.usatoday.com/life/televis...l-photos_x.htm