Who is going to watch American Idol tonight?

I agree...the guys are soo much better....but I did like kellie ...even though she can be annoying at times

It was boring but if I think back to the other show's beginnings ... so were they.
Until they get rid of the people who should not be there at all, both male & female, I think that it is to early to tell.
My guess is that the judges would like a good male winner who could equal Kelly's staying power and success with her sales.

I am just not as imperssed with Mandisa as everyone else is. No one is really blowing me away from the girls side. I haven't really seen the guys show so I will have to watch the whole thing tonight!

Originally Posted by Phenomsmom

CheeeCheeze mom can watch American Idol for real tonight instead of making believe itts on!

Click to expand...

Yeah, I have to agree, the girls just don't have it this year. The guys are a good bunch though

Id be a terrible Judge because all those girls last night sounded great to me...I wouldnt know which one of them to bounce out of there

Heather!!!!!!!!!!!

I should have mentioned that Brenna is on the top of my list to get kicked off. Can't stand her!

I agree with the rest - I just wasn't all that impressed with the girls. Not with any of them. Ayla, Mandisa and Kellie were pretty good, but none of them great. Brenna and Heather would be my bottom two.

Is anyone else just plain getting tired of Paula and Simon's staged squabbles? Or just of Paula in general? I swear, if I were a contestant I would just tell her that I don't even care what she has to say because to her everyone is a star.

She was telling everyone they were astar last night wasn't she. I think she feels bad because she knows after she and randy say somehting nice Simon is goign to crush them! LOL

Originally Posted by Phenomsmom

She was telling everyone they were astar last night wasn't she. I think she feels bad because she knows after she and randy say somehting nice Simon is goign to crush them! LOL

Click to expand...

I agree with you. Paula is tactful with her criticism, but Simon is just unecessarliy harsh. Maybe that's what people want to see. I dunno

Katherine has a beautiful face & voice.
If she can just learn to entertain, she has real possibilities.

Heather & Brenna must go.

I agree - I don't really like Brenna!

I do really like Paris and Kelley tho - I think they are both really good - they are my 2 favorites.

I think Mandissa did pretty good too, I like her too!

The rest of them...I wasn't really even impressed that much

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

I should have mentioned that Brenna is on the top of my list to get kicked off. Can't stand her!

Click to expand...

She really grinds on me! At work this morning we were talking about how she reminds us of that gal last year who was from New York with all of the attitude. That gets tiring real fast!

Originally Posted by jeanor

She really grinds on me! At work this morning we were talking about how she reminds us of that gal last year who was from New York with all of the attitude. That gets tiring real fast!

Click to expand...

Definately!

She seems so fake when she was standing next to Ryan and smiling at the camera - fake fake fake smile!

I agree Heather for sure. I don't know about Brenna as some people might like her attitude. Nothing really stood out last night.

OK, I can get excited for real today the boys are on RIGHT!?!? I'm not confused again am I? JK I can't wait to see, I mean hear them sing

Wow! That's my reaction after watching Chris Daughtry. I'd have to say he's the favorite going in to it right now.

Overall I thought the guys were much better than the girls. I also think that they should boot 1 guy and 3 girls. LOL Sway really didn't bring it tonight, and I think he's out.

Hehe, he's been my favorite from the auditions!!! Did you see Bo was in the audience tonight?

Originally Posted by valanhb

Wow! That's my reaction after watching Chris Daughtry. I'd have to say he's the favorite going in to it right now.

Overall I thought the guys were much better than the girls. I also think that they should boot 1 guy and 3 girls. LOL Sway really didn't bring it tonight, and I think he's out.

Click to expand...

I think David or Kevin could also be in trouble tonight. As pretty as he looked singing, Ace did horrible.

I agree...Ace may be in over his pretty head.
I thought that Elliott was amazing.