Who is going to watch American Idol tonight?

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

I already checked the results so far in that too

Click to expand...

Karen, you are so bad!

I'm looking forward to tomorrow when the guys are on...Chris and Ace....

Originally Posted by menagerie mama

I'm looking forward to tomorrow when the guys are on...Chris and Ace....

Click to expand...

Me too...I hope that they guys are better than the girls were last night....only a few were good

I didn't like Mandisa or that Becky girl. I didn't get to see the rest. Kellie did bad last night too. I was really disappointed in what I saw.

Can we vote off more than 2? There were a few that were really good, then a bunch of mediocre performances, then some that just really need to go home. Their performances were actually painful to watch.

Was anyone else overall less-than-impressed with the guys? Like Karen said with the girls (which I didn't get to see), there were a few who were good, most of the rest mediocre, and a few just need to go home.

I'm a little dissapointed in the guys tonight...no one really blew me away. And, sadly, Ace Young the Hot Hot Hottie didn't floor me either.





But he's still really hot...

Yeah only about four guys were good....

in order of best:

1. Chris Daughty
2. Taylor hicks
3. Elliot
4. ace

Originally Posted by OllyExtra05

But he's still really hot...

Click to expand...

How many votes is he going to get just because he was singing about being warm and naked?

I think there are 2 obvious ones that need to go. Overall, I thought they did OK. I liked Ace, Chris & Elliot (although I don't think he is the best male vocalist in 5 years). Taylor wasn't as bad as I thought he would be. I cringed the whole way through "Sway's" performance, even though the judges seem to like it!

No wonder I was "hot" last night-it was Ace!!! Some of the crooner's are going to have to go to. Bucky was pretty good too.

I just couldn't understand everyone reaction to Sway's performance. I just didn't like it.

Originally Posted by GailC

Bucky was pretty good too.

Click to expand...

Gail, I cringed the whole way through his performance also. I think part of that may be regional. Up here we are not known for our love of Southern rockers... although I did love Bo!

I pretty much agree with everyone here. There are three who should go, IMO, based on last night's performances. Sway, Bobby (sad, since he's the only "local boy" who made it from Denver), and David.

Taylor Hicks really pleasantly surprised me last night. His "dancing" drove me nuts previously, to the point of distraction. Last night he chilled it enough for me to actually hear him, and it was good.

It will be interesting to see who goes and who stays tonight.

Originally Posted by snosrap5

I just couldn't understand everyone reaction to Sway's performance. I just didn't like it.

Click to expand...

We didn't really like it eiter, and were really surprised with the judges reactions.

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

How many votes is he going to get just because he was singing about being warm and naked?

Click to expand...

oh my gosh.... I thought the same thing last night! He really knows how to 'work it'

In general, I thought the girls did better than the guys as a group. Is anyone else tired of Taylor's "moves"?

Originally Posted by jeanor

Is anyone else tired of Taylor's "moves"?

Click to expand...

Since the west coast hasn't seen it yet, all I am going to say is that is was excruciating having to listen to those leaving sing again!

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

Since the west coast hasn't seen it yet, all I am going to say is that is was excruciating having to listen to those leaving sing again!

Click to expand...

I saw the beginning of the girls and who the final 3 were that were the lowest scores - who got kicked off for guys and girls?!

Becky, Stevie, Bobby and Patrick all had the lowest number of votes. I was surprised by Patrick. I thought Bobby did a better job singing last night than he did on Wednesday night.