my cats love Soulistic Good Karma (shredded chicken in a broth like gravy). it's in the green can and the Harvest Sunrise (Good Karma with bits of pumpkin) in the orange can. I avoid the flavors in the gelee as they have ingredients and thickeners that I'm not crazy about.
I probably should try going to Petco more. I favor ordering off of Amazon as we're in a rural area (about 30 minute drive from Petco) but there's something to be said for not having to buy an entire case of each kind.