Raven gets them whenever he wants. But that's because he has cancer and he has days where all he eats are his treats. (which are mostly Fancy Feast Gourmet Gold, and one other kind of "junky" dry food) I also have several other treats open, but they seem to go stale fast so I'm moving more towards the cheap dry kibbles for treats. My other 2 cats get a couple treats if they see Raven is getting treats. They get jealous otherwise. But they don't get nearly as much as he does, and often don't want any treats.