Ok, I think that I have found the best litter....the best part is that it is Disney hahaha I am not even joking, I was at wit's end and so I grabbed Disney Aristocats cat little. It is pine crumbles not pellets like feline pine. I loved FP, but Marcie didn't like to bury her poo in it. Couldn't fine the FP that wasn't in pellets around here. Anywhoo, the Disney stuff clumps just like clumping litter and covers smells just like the FP and it lasts for a full two weeks in between complete cleanings (I do scoop every day, but who doesn't lol) One of the really nice things about this litter is that it doesn't track like the clumping stuff and even if I do step on it, it doesn't stick to the bottom of my feet.