That is a bummer. Was he eating dry and wet at one point? What kind of canned is he eating now. I am trying to have Sandi lose weight (13yrs @ approx. 12lbs) she has some manecoone (sp?). I am finding out that dry isn't good after all. I am going to a pet store tomorrow to see if they have the raw food (here in this part of PA they are still behind or unless they all make there own raw mix). I plan on making it myself down the line but what to convert with a ready mix first. I hope they have it.