So I ran out of Puffs Greenies yesterday so I was at walmart looking for them. They didn't have em but I picked up something called SmartyKat Benefit Bitz. They are 100% Salmon treats though I don't know how they can say that when you read the ingredients it says Salmon, mineral oil, vitamin C, and Rosemary extract.. But Puff is going nuts trying to get to them! He's already had 5 pieces and I'm cutting him off till tomorrow...lol. He's trying his best to get more though.