Introduction of Stray/New Kitty to Four Older Cats

shellybean

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Sep 16, 2013
Messages
4
Purraise
0
Hello!  I posted this same thread on the Stray/Feral board, but figured it's also relative to behavior so maybe someone here has some advice.

About a month and a half ago, we noticed a little Tortie hanging around on our deck.  The first couple days she ran away if we tried to go outside. Then, all of a sudden, she came immediately to my 12 year-old daughter when she went out to talk to her.  She wasn't dirty or matted, but she was skinny as a rail.  I thought she couldn't be more than about 7 months old at the time.  The fact that she came to my daughter and then to me, did the whole rubbing/nuzzling thing and let us pet her seemed to indicate she was either a neighborhood pet that wandered or a kitty who had been lost or abandoned.  I resisted feeding her at first because I didn't want her to keep hanging around our house if she already had a home. Eventually, we couldn't stand it anymore because she was out there all the time and we started feeding her.  We built her a little outdoor shelter and regularly fed, watered and interacted with her.  About a week after we made her the shelter, she was attacked in the middle of the night by a large male.  I ran out and chased him off and she was unhurt but terrified to the point of peeing all over herself, her bed, and me.  That was the last straw for me - I brought her inside and kept her in our bathroom for a couple weeks.  Eventually, she transitioned to my daughter's bedroom which is bigger and has windows and is much more comfortable for her.

We already have four cats - all rescues:  three 14 year-old siblings and one 8 year-old.   The three siblings we rescued as tiny kittens from our garage when their mother abandoned them, so we're pretty much all they've ever known.  The 8 year-old was a rescue from a shelter.  All of them are pretty easygoing and were clearly aware of the new addition, but curious more than anything.  I wouldn't let her near them or share any of their stuff because I didn't know whether she'd been exposed or infected with anything that she could pass on to them (i.e., FLV, FELV, rabies, etc.).  I wasn't sure what to do because I didn't really have the money to invest in spaying and vaccinating a cat I wasn't sure we could keep.  Long story short, we finally did exactly that about a week and a half ago.  

We had been keeping them all separate but letting Bambi (the stray) out in the house to stretch her legs and explore when the other kitties were upstairs sleeping behind a closed door.  She was out one evening and one of the other cats got out and came downstairs to get something to eat and Bambi went after her like the Tasmanian Devil.  I chased them down and had Bambi stopped at the foot of the stairs while my other poor kitty escaped upstairs.  I didn't have a water bottle near me and was just scared for my other babies, so when Bambi started up the stairs, I, foolishly, acted on instinct and reached down to grab her.  Well, you can imagine what happened next.  Four bite wounds, dozens of scratches, a round of antibiotics and two weeks later, I'm healed up, but her aggression toward the other cats still concerns me.  

She's almost two weeks post-surgery, feeling fine and behaving beautifully when she's in the house alone with us.  She plays, she mews, she lets us pet her.  But, as soon as she sees one of the other cats, she's devil kitty.  Someone from a rescue agency in the area told me that many of her behaviors are hallmarks of the Tortie breed and suggested I get a kennel and put her in the middle of everything and just let her stay there until she can be civil when she's out.  Well, we're trying that and it's not going swimmingly.  We've even let her out a few times with one and then two of the older cats (one female and the male).  They clearly had a conversation with her and she has steered clear of actually attacking them but is certainly very on edge and appears to be biding her time.  She did go after the "patriarch" last night from behind and he set her straight, though not before losing a bit of fur.  Side note, he's double-pawed and has a full set of 24 claws in his arsenal.  

The one time we let her out with the two older ones and the youngest, Smudge, it wasn't 30 seconds before she charged Smudge and attacked.  I sprayed her and she ran but he didn't stand up to her at all.  In fact, the older female, seemed to get mad at Smudge for not standing his ground (he's declawed BTW, came to us that way).  He such a sweetheart and it's breaking my heart that he's being bullied by this little snot ball.  If she'd give him a chance, I would bet good money they'd be best friends since they are very much alike (he's a black cat) in personality and playfulness.

I know this process takes a while.  But she's been in our house almost two months now and I'm running myself ragged trying to avoid death and destruction while taking care of all of them AND my family.  My daughter would be heartbroken (as would I) to give her up, but I'm seriously thinking that might be the best thing for her and for us.  She would probably do very well being the only pet in a household.  On the other hand, I also have this idealistic vision of all of them being friends and my house being peaceful again.  I don't want to continue to restrict her young life, but I cannot compromise the quality of my other cats' lives, especially at the advanced age of three of them.

I've tried the homeopathic sprays and drops (Safe Space, Nature's Miracle) that are supposed to calm kitties down and none of them seem to work.  I've tried feeding them in front of one another with her in the cage and the others a safe distance away so they all understand there's no need to fight over food and they can get used to being near each other.  They don't share litter boxes, water or food bowls. Nothing has worked.  We're all gone most of the day with work and school, so it feels wrong to keep her closed up in a bedroom with only a couple hours out to roam around when we get home.

I just don't know what to do.  If someone can give me some advice or a glimmer of hope that it's just going to take time, I'd really appreciate it.  I know no one has a crystal ball, but I've never had to deal with anything like this and I'm frazzled.  My husband says we should just let her out and let them deal with it themselves, but I'm worried because the younger one doesn't seem inclined to fight back at all and the older two she's met, while they are certainly in charge, are getting very frail and I'm scared she could cause them to break a bone or worse, if she were to engage them in a battle.  The last one of the the older three already has serious nervous issues, so I really think she might have a breakdown having to deal with Bambi.  No joke.

Any help will be more than appreciated!
 

rude holstein

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Sep 19, 2013
Messages
3
Purraise
1
Location
Tucson Arizona
hi I am a newbie but I have some ideas. my Goonda was abandoned under my house. 7 months old, 2 new kittens and pregnant again. I borrowed traps from a rescue group. our humane society has free spay/neuter checkup and shots for ferals. A friend took the babies, I put Goonda (Hindi for thug) in spare bedroom with door shut. took at least a month before I even saw her but I d go in every am and pm and sit on the floor and just talk. one night she gathered all her courage and came out from hiding and THREW herself on me. Now she was my baby- but what about my 4 cats? I put up a regular screen door secured to the bedroom doorway. Place chair either side so cats can see, hear smell each other. Closed be solid door when I m gone and at bedtime. Some nights I sleep in there with her. Gradually she started coming out and my 4 stayed in their room. one night a big skirmish and Goonda spent the next 2 months hiding in the bedroom, sometimes under the dresser for days. we put the screen back up. we took it down. I slept with G some more nights. Now everyone is in general population CAUTIOUSLY. I can sit on the couch with an oldie and the newbie on either side. Birdseed on the porch works wonders, they can all watch the birds thru the sliding glass door.
when did I bring G in? February 2012!! It takes time, patience, trial and error and determination to save a life. when I get totally frustrated I remember seeing Goonda take on a 6ft rattlesnake to protect her babies and then I know it's worth it
 

catspaw66

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
5,508
Purraise
1,616
Location
Waldron, Arkansas
You really need to do a proper introduction   www.thecatsite.com/a/introducing-cats-to-cats   Until she is comfortable with your resident cats, she will revert back to her instinctual state whenever confronted.

Tortie is not a breed, just a color pattern. We sometimes talk of "tortitude" when describing their behavior, but it really is no different than any other cat. Most of the cats in the world are Domestic Short/Long Hairs, also known lovingly as 'moggies'

Some cats just take longer to assimilate than others. Your cat, being an outdoor cat brought inside, is more likely to take a little bit longer. Don't give up and put her back outside, please. There is a good chance that she will calm down in time.

Try a Feliway plug-in or two in the house. They seem to do the best job of calming cats.
 

rude holstein

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Sep 19, 2013
Messages
3
Purraise
1
Location
Tucson Arizona
we still have aggression issues but omg it's the spraying! Eddie did that before we got the newbie. She also sprays. Eddie hit the same spot twice in an hour last night. strategic areas are covered by shower curtains and towels that can go right in the washer. vet says it's behavioral not medical after exams. the newbie has been monopolizing me and the couch lately. I think separate play times would help. how do the plugins do any good when we have windows open and air circulating all the time? they are kinda expensive. also we have 8 litter boxes clean and available at all times except when I'm at work
 
Top