This is a staple in my house, and I like it because it is so high protein, has no fish, and no carrageenan. My FIV positive cat has been eating about half Holistic Select, half a variety of other high quality wet pates for over a year now and her blood tests at her annual vet visit came back perfect!
It comes in 13 oz cans which is very cost effective, and I get the chicken, turkey, and lamb flavors. Both of my cats like it pretty well, although Delilah doesn't seem to like the lamb so much anymore. But I have a friend who's cats love this in lamb the most, so it all depends.