I have my senior on Felidae. I got the small bag end of sept and its not quite gone yet. Lucky for me none of the other cats are eating it!! Ox and the rest are on Nutro natural which was one sale today so I picked up 2 bags. For moist-its mainly a treat for the cats as they only get about 1T or so daily. I add extra water to the boys dishes to make sure they are getting a tiny bit extra water!!