Help Choosing New Food

[river]

I tried a few Eagle Pack flavors and they were all loaf, my boy didn't like them too much either.

 

[river]

In case anyone is interested, my finicky boy will eat, in order of preference-

1.All Fancy Feast grilled
2.Wysong chicken and beef stew
3.Tiki food
4.Avoderm Select cuts
Kind of likes-
4.Wellness pouches
5.Nutro pouches
6.Merrick's Cowboy Cookout

Will not eat, or eats a little -
Innova
Wellness
Natural Balance
Evangers
Most Merricks
Eagle
Most Avoderm
Felidae
Nature's Variety
Organix
Fromm Beef
Pinnacle
Nature's Logic
Evo
Evo 95%
California Natural

 

[sharky]

Originally Posted by river

In case anyone is interested, my finicky boy will eat -

1.All Fancy Feast grilled

AHH kitty crack

 

[river]

Originally Posted by river

In case anyone is interested, my finicky boy will eat, in order of preference-

1.All Fancy Feast grilled
2.Wysong chicken and beef stew
3.Tiki food
4.Avoderm Select cuts
Kind of likes-
4.Wellness pouches
5.Nutro pouches
6.Merrick's Cowboy Cookout

Will not eat, or eats a little -
Innova
Wellness
Natural Balance
Evangers
Most Merricks
Eagle
Most Avoderm
Felidae
Nature's Variety
Organix
Fromm Beef
Pinnacle
Nature's Logic
Evo
Evo 95%
California Natural

Found another one my cat likes, tied for number 2 is-

Nature's Variety Homestyle Prairie

 

[saya]

the "wysong archetype" is dry cold pressed and concentrated. the good thing about this stuff is that you can feed it dry or add water to it and basically make it whatever consistency you like...chucky or gravy or a combo of the two...
this is good stuff, pricey but goes a long way