I just received a case from mr chewy and it smells rotten! I don't know what alligator is suppose to smell like? My kitties wouldn't touch it and I'm wondering if it's bad or is that how is suppose to smell?
Wow, I just had to google this - didn't know Wild Calling offered an alligator flavor ??
I've used their duck, rabbit, and bison flavor foods - my cats will eat, but not enthusiastically and I have to put toppers on it, so I know it's not one of their faves.
If I were you, I would contact Chewy and let them know so you can return it. If it smells bad + cats won't eat it, that's not a good sign!
I've never tried it with my cats, however, I recently spoke with a woman who sampled it with her one year old cat. She said the cat would not touch it. The cat otherwise really likes WC's rabbit burrow and other formulas but the 'gator was a definite bomb.