TheCatSite.com › Forums › General Forums › The Cat Lounge › American Idol - who gets voted off 05/17/06?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

American Idol - who gets voted off 05/17/06? - Page 2

post #31 of 46
Taylor just bothers me. Is was too much like a show you would see in Las Vegas. I want Kat to win because I might actually buy her cds and stuff but I know for sure I wouldn't buy Taylors.
post #32 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phenomsmom
Taylor just bothers me. Is was too much like a show you would see in Las Vegas. I want Kat to win because I might actually buy her cds and stuff but I know for sure I wouldn't buy Taylors.
Thats how I feel too - I think Kat is more of the "American Idol" that will get out there and sell cds - on the other hand, I don't think Taylor will sell many cds - your right - he does seem like you'd see him in a show in Vegas!

Sure he puts on a good show, but what about when he's recording? I just don't think he'll succeed as an American Idol, IMO.

I'm just mad that he's made it farther than Chris or Mandissa did- they both could sing 1000's times better than Taylor does.
post #33 of 46
I hope Taylor wins, just becuase I really don't like Katharine.

I haven't bought any of the idols cd's and don't plan on starting, once this season is over i'll be looking forward to the next one Where once again the best singer will get the boot and the whole thing is repeated
post #34 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trouts mom
But Kat is a better singer than Taylor. And that is what this competition is about..singing. Taylor does not have a good range, he always sounds the same. I do enjoy him, but I really do think Kat is more of an Idol.

I like his singing better than I do Katharine's. I know nothing about range.
It's my preference.

I would never buy anything she put out.
I'd go see Taylor. I love Joe Cocker, and Taylor reminds me of that.
He has been in the Top Group since the beginning.
Kat has had 4 bad weeks.....well, bad in the sense that she did not do as well as the others. IDOL is the whole package to me, and she does not have it.
post #35 of 46
I think this is going to get very intersting now
post #36 of 46
Thread Starter 
It's amazing how the opinions vary on here.........I think Taylor is the best and would buy his cds/go to his concerts in a heartbeat. That's one great thing about TCS. Not only do we all have fantastic kits, but we all have great opinions! Now, I think they should start an American Kitty Idol contest!!! Who want's to enter their kit????
post #37 of 46
Hello, Miss. We are 2 cats hoo have a story thred in PAWS & REFLECT. We rite catnap storees. Last summer, we rote a story about some kitties here hoo went to KITTY IDOL!
If you go to our fred and look at the first coupla pages, you can reed our storee. We hope u do it and that u like it.

Shenandoah and Humble Kitty

Quote:
Originally Posted by kittylover4ever
It's amazing how the opinions vary on here.........I think Taylor is the best and would buy his cds/go to his concerts in a heartbeat. That's one great thing about TCS. Not only do we all have fantastic kits, but we all have great opinions! Now, I think they should start an American Kitty Idol contest!!! Who want's to enter their kit????
post #38 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by kittylover4ever
It's amazing how the opinions vary on here.........I think Taylor is the best and would buy his cds/go to his concerts in a heartbeat. That's one great thing about TCS. Not only do we all have fantastic kits, but we all have great opinions! Now, I think they should start an American Kitty Idol contest!!! Who want's to enter their kit????



post #39 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by kittylover4ever
It's amazing how the opinions vary on here.........I think Taylor is the best and would buy his cds/go to his concerts in a heartbeat. That's one great thing about TCS. Not only do we all have fantastic kits, but we all have great opinions! Now, I think they should start an American Kitty Idol contest!!! Who want's to enter their kit????
Sure! I'd enter Harley! He'd be a rocker - like Chris
post #40 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by babyharley
Sure! I'd enter Harley! He'd be a rocker - like Chris

hahhaa, I love this, Trout would be like Kelly Pickler...so cute but sometimes annoying!
post #41 of 46
All I know is that Nate wouldn't make it past the first round, he has the worst screechiest meow I've ever heard. My daughter said when she first heard him meow, it sounded as if someone was strangling him.

Back to the subject at hand, I like Katherine and she's been one of my favorites from the very beginning. I hope she wins, but I won't be upset if Taylor does.

IMO when she complains to the judges about their comments, sometimes what she says is true... like last week with the song choice - I was glad she stood up for herself, and I've never heard them say to any of the male singers that they are trying to imitate the original artist. Then with one of the songs, when she did try to "make it her own" they complained and said she should just sing the melody. They REALLY contradict themselves sometimes.

Quote:
Originally Posted by babyharley
I'm just mad that he's made it farther than Chris or Mandissa did- they both could sing 1000's times better than Taylor does.
I agree, I think they were better than any of the last three. I really thought Chris was going to win.
post #42 of 46
I would love Taylor to win,as he is so unlike a 'typical pop star',I have liked him rom the very begining!
Katherine is a great singer,but maybe not as original as Taylor.
We dont get the show untill Friday night here,so it will be really tempting to have a sneaky look at he winner on here
post #43 of 46
I'd go see Taylor. I love Joe Cocker, and Taylor reminds me of that.


Definitely agree, he has that Joe Cocker type of voice. That is who I thought he reminded me of at the very beginning. I believe he will win the whole thing mostly because of his showmanship, and he definitely has that. Kat on the other hand does not, but to me, has the better voice.

Paulena
post #44 of 46
I want Taylor to win!! I don't like KAT! She is a great singer but I don't like her. Taylor is more personable and is the better entertainer. MHO
post #45 of 46
Susie, this week we need a "don't care" option
post #46 of 46
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by AbbysMom
Susie, this week we need a "don't care" option

Ok, I'll go start a new thread and put that in there.........I wish you Chris people wouldn't swing over to Taylor now, but I know we all like who we all like
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Cat Lounge
TheCatSite.com › Forums › General Forums › The Cat Lounge › American Idol - who gets voted off 05/17/06?