Taking my Cat back...should I or shouldn't I...?

catwomando

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
11
Purraise
1
Hello! I recently found this brilliant site and I'm so glad I did
Here is my question and situation for all you feline lovers...I just need some advice and don't really have anywhere to turn. This is a bit long but I want whoever wishes to leave advice to know my full story with my dear cat and I.

About 4 years ago I moved in with my then boyfriend who kind of manipulated me into staying with him. One of his tactics which he used before with girlfriends was getting a pet. I was younger and naive and fell for is guy, let's call him Nathan and it was my first serious relationship, but later I would find out he wasn't exactly who he made med think he was.

I always wanted to adopt a cat and we ended up adopting two from my friend that was fostering a kitten litter and their mom. Now the one I chose was actually not part of the litter, he was found on the street two days after my friend fostered the kittens and luckily when he was introduced to the litter the mother accepted him. I named him Klaus, the other cat Nathan named Cosmo. They are both very different, Klaus has a dog like personality, he loves to eat and naturally learned to play fetch and is very clumsy, loud ,intelligent, in your face, but very sweet and has never scratched or attacked me. Cosmo is very shy and delicate cat.

Nathan and I started to fight a lot and he got very emotionally manipulative and controlling. Klaus was always such a comfort when I was upset and emotional. I stayed with Nathan because I had hope and I felt like a had a home with him and our cats. I didn't want to leave them. When Nathan crossed the line during a fight I knew it was time to leave. I've thought about leaving before but was worried he wouldn't let me take the cats. I immediately moved out and had to leave the cats behind because where I ended up living didn't allow them.

About 3 months later I decided to take my cats to my father's temporarily until I lived somewhere where I could keep them. Unfortunately Nathan told me he was too close to Cosmo and because he didn't like Klaus he only let me take him. This was fine with me since I was always closer to Klaus and adored him. It was love at first cat, I decided to take him to my fathers temporarily because my father lives in a pretty big home in the suburbs with his wife and another cat and they are both big cat lovers. Their second cat recently passed away and they were very open to taking Klaus. I flew 2 hours to where they live, which was ok, Klaus only meowed a few times and tried to get out of his cage once but overall he dealt with it fine.

This was around two years ago. I recently moved in with my new loving awesome boyfriend of 1.5 years into our own apartment. It's a new building, we are on the 25th floor, one bedroom, around 700 square feet. My boyfriend knows how much I love and miss my cat and is very supportive of me and willing to bringing him back.

Now here lies the problem...my father and I do not have a good relationship because in the past he was abusive and a terrible husband to my mother ( they divorced 20 years ago). His new wife did not want to give Klaus back. Even though the arrangement of keeping Klaus was temporary until I had a home for him with me. After some recent discussion my father and his wife are letting me take Klaus under the condition I never leave him with them again. That's fine with me. My only reason to visit them was to see Klaus anyway. Every time I would visit Klaus he was super happy and purred a lot (he very rarely purrs in general) and would follow me around everywhere. However he is also very attached to my dad now. The other cat my dad has is a shy timid cat and while they do chase and play together at night, during the day they don't hang out or sleep together.

Also, my father and his wife let Klaus outside even though I never wanted him to be an outdoor cat for these reasons: my father lives in the suburbs but they are by busy streets, a lot of neighbors have dogs, and Klaus isn't afraid of anything and will just go up to any dog, so I was worried for his safety that he would get attacked. I also don't want him getting sick from eating grass from my dad's neighbors home that uses pesticide on their lawn. Also Klaus was sprayed in the face by a skunk a few months ago and his entire eye was swollen. I always worried he would get attacked by something bigger then him. My father and his wife also don't buy the best cat food either and Klaus is now a little bit overweight. He's a big breed, I'm not sure what kind, I've been told by friends he looks like a Norwegian Forest or a Maine Coon mix. He weighs about 18-20 pounds now, I think for his breed mix 12-15 is normal.

All in all, I think he would have a happier, safer life with me...but I am kind of on the fence. I've missed him so terribly but I don't want to be selfish. ..Yes he is attached to my father and his wife and has a ton of space and a fellow cat to play with and goes outside...but he would get a ton of attention and affection from me and my boyfriend. However he would be an indoor cat here where I live. And he would be living in a much smaller space with no chance of gong outdoors.. (He live in the city and don't even have a balcony or terrace).

So I am asking you fellow readers what you think you would do in my shoes... Any advice would mean the world to me... I am going to visit my family and where my father lives in about a month. Just to remind Klaus is about 5 years old now and has been living at my father's around 2 1/2 years-3years.
 

NewYork1303

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jun 9, 2015
Messages
3,025
Purraise
2,015
Location
Washington State
I would take him back too, so long as you're sure that you can offer him a home forever, without being forced to live somewhere you can't have him again. If you take him back, its only fair to him that he gets to be with you forever after that. Cats can have a difficult time adjusting so changing their living situation all of the time isn't really fair to them. If you can give him a stable, loving home for the rest of his life, of course you should have him.

Having cats stay indoors all the time is safer for them and he'll likely adjust. He will likely adjust to being without a second cat to play with as well, though he'll need more attention from you and your boyfriend.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5

catwomando

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
11
Purraise
1
Thanks for the advice everyone.. I really really appreciate it and I agree with you both..
 

misterwhiskers

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 7, 2014
Messages
2,013
Purraise
714
I'd take him back too, given especially the fact they let him outside. Just get a couple cat condos, and expect that he'll be restless for a little while. But I think he will be very happy to have his mama back. [emoji]128570[/emoji]
 

Columbine

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
12,921
Purraise
6,224
Location
The kitty playground
Klaus bonded to you first, and he'll never forget that. Cats can and do adapt to living 100% indoors (the only exceptions are some ex-ferals).

Having said that, you and your boyfriend have to be fully committed to making the apartment as cat friendly as possible. This means cat trees and other forms of vertical space access (cat shelves, spots to sit and look out the window etc). It means committing to daily interactive playtime, and most likely visible litterbox placement. Your boyfriend has to be on board with all of this before Klaus moves in. If you haven't already, you need to check the terms of the lease regarding cats...Sadly, some landlords still insist on the barbaric practice of declawing.

I'm sorry if I'm stating the obvious. It's simply that you've made it clear that this move will have to be permanent (as in Klaus can never go back to his current home). I hope this makes things a little clearer for you :)

Oh, and welcome to TCS :wavey:
 

kalicat24

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Jun 19, 2015
Messages
13
Purraise
3
Location
Indiana
I would keep him. If he has become attached to you, he would miss you even more.cats always remember the first one to love them, and since its you, he would be devistated. and once your settled in, you could adopt him a friend! in the suburbs, cats get hit by cars all the time. thats how i lost harriet. and overfeeding can cause a cat to die. plus the grass poison and dogs=noooo!
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #9

catwomando

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
11
Purraise
1
Klaus bonded to you first, and he'll never forget that. Cats can and do adapt to living 100% indoors (the only exceptions are some ex-ferals).

Having said that, you and your boyfriend have to be fully committed to making the apartment as cat friendly as possible. This means cat trees and other forms of vertical space access (cat shelves, spots to sit and look out the window etc). It means committing to daily interactive playtime, and most likely visible litterbox placement. Your boyfriend has to be on board with all of this before Klaus moves in. If you haven't already, you need to check the terms of the lease regarding cats...Sadly, some landlords still insist on the barbaric practice of declawing.

I'm sorry if I'm stating the obvious. It's simply that you've made it clear that this move will have to be permanent (as in Klaus can never go back to his current home). I hope this makes things a little clearer for you :)

Oh, and welcome to TCS :wavey:

Thanks so much for your feedback Columbine! I will definitely get a cat tree and give my cat as much attention as possible. My issue now is he will no longer have a great view outside.. We live on the 30th floor with only the view of our city... And cats are near sighted so I'm worried he won't get as much visual stimulation from looking outside since you can't see any trees and birds don't fly by. :/ other than that luckily our landlord is cool with cats and dogs and our apartment has space for Klaus to explore and climb, but I hope he doesn't get too lonely if my boyfriend and I are both working and he's left all alone while we are gone.
 

Columbine

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
12,921
Purraise
6,224
Location
The kitty playground
There are other things you can do for visual stimulation - there's YouTube videos and dvds of 'cat tv' you could play for him....you could even get a fish tank to entertain him too!

Taking a different route, there are tons of puzzle toys and balls available now. You could also try something like that when you're at work. A timed feeder can help break up the day too.

I wouldn't worry too much about loneliness - cats are generally very good at being single pets. So long as he has plenty of indoor stimulation he'll be fine.

http://www.thecatsite.com/a/beating-boredom-what-indoor-cat-owners-need-to-know
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #12

catwomando

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
11
Purraise
1
Thank you all so so so so much for your responses and advice!!! Klaus is now happily back with me!!!! My boyfriend and I are trying to give him as much attention and play time as we can. He seems very happy he's been purring a lot and snuggling with us at night. The only problem is I think he is still adjusting to his new home because he's been meowing a lot.. I hope he gets settled in soon!
 

Kat0121

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 23, 2014
Messages
15,048
Purraise
20,376
Location
Sunny Florida
Thank you all so so so so much for your responses and advice!!! Klaus is now happily back with me!!!! My boyfriend and I are trying to give him as much attention and play time as we can. He seems very happy he's been purring a lot and snuggling with us at night. The only problem is I think he is still adjusting to his new home because he's been meowing a lot.. I hope he gets settled in soon!
That's great. He's probably meowing a lot to tell you how much he missed you and happy he is to be with you again. 
 

tallyollyopia

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
1,827
Purraise
1,032
All right, I don't know a lot about cats, but I do know a lot about relationships. I don't know if your new boyfriend (congrats, by the way) really understands what it means to live with a cat. Here's what I would do in your situation, assuming I had the time and funds for it: I would cat the house. What I mean by that is making sure the litterboxes are where you want them, getting the scratching posts and/or condos ready, and make sure that everything you plan to get for Klaus is gotten. Then live in it, together and catless, for a month. Sometimes, and I'm not saying your current boyfriend is like this, the sight of all those cat toys and paraphernalia can irritate people. I'm not sure why; it's one of the few  things about owning cats that I've never had a problem with. See if your current boyfriend (or you, because you've been cat-free for a long time now) can handle living in that kind of environment. If the answer is a resounding "yes", then by all means you should bring Klaus home to live with you. Both of you will be devoted pet parents and will love little Klaus as much as any cat can possibly desire.
 
Last edited:
Top