We don't have a toaster oven for space reasons. We should because those big KitchenAid electric ovens suck power fast enough to overheat the electric meter.
What we do use a lot is our Cuisinart Griddler. This is our third one. We keep upgrading. We kept the last one because we got waffle plates for it and it makes much better waffles than the waffle iron. The latest Griddler has more control but is much heavier. If I'm making fajitas, I cook each serving as needed on one Griddler and heat the flour tortillas on the other. It makes great grilled sandwiches, quesadillas, and a host of other things.
What we do use a lot is our Cuisinart Griddler. This is our third one. We keep upgrading. We kept the last one because we got waffle plates for it and it makes much better waffles than the waffle iron. The latest Griddler has more control but is much heavier. If I'm making fajitas, I cook each serving as needed on one Griddler and heat the flour tortillas on the other. It makes great grilled sandwiches, quesadillas, and a host of other things.