Should I Get Another Cat?

mio-nozawa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 23, 2014
Messages
21
Purraise
17
Location
Austin, TX
I wasn’t sure where to post this, so forgive me if this is the wrong place. I am just looking for people’s thoughts and opinions since this has been going round in my head for months now and I feel like I am just going around in circles. I would appreciate anyone’s opinion.

Backstory: In 2013 my husband and I got two kittens, Mio (pictured) and Nozawa. Nozawa was and is more my husband’s cat, and Mio was completely attached to me. Mio was the sweetest little cat who was always happy to see you, loved attention and had such a sweet little personality, I loved her so much. In 2016 she got sick suddenly and we found out she had FeLV (Nozawa didn’t have it). She passed soon after and I was (and am still), heartbroken and devastated about it.

Afterwards we would put down a deposit for 2 exotic SH kittens in a future litter from a very reputable breeder. We decided to get 2 as our other cat Nozawa is kind of cranky and we wanted them to have a playmate. While we waited for her to have kittens available (it would take 8 months), we decided to foster some kittens with our local animal shelter. We did pretty good until this one kitten came along in a litter of 6 who was super cute, and we ended up foster failing her. So after we picked up the two shorthair exotic kittens - and we now have 4 cats.

The two exotic kittens are sweet, great with strangers, great at the vet, very healthy, social, but neither of them really like getting pet or like getting attention. They love food and will sleep with us at night, but if you try and pet or brush them they will kind of move out of the way.

Our foster fail kitten as well sometimes likes being pet, is very sweet, but she also doesn’t like being fussed over at all.

I really miss having a cat who was always happy to see me and loved attention. I have seriously been considering getting another cat, but the stigma of having 5 cats is really holding me back. When I tell people we have 4 cats, their eyes go kind of wide, so I can't imagine telling them 5 cats. Though part of me thinks I have this one life and if it makes me happy who cares?

We can afford it (all our cats have insurance and we feed quality wet food), have the time, our cats like other cats, and space isn’t really an issue (though we do plan to move to a slightly bigger place in 2 years), but still I keep going around and around. There have been a couple of rescue persians that I was on the brink of adopting, but just as I resolved to do so they ended up being adopted by someone else. Also I feel like there is just no guarantee how a cat is actually going to behave once we get them home, or if they are a kitten they can change so much as they get older.

My other worry is that no matter what kind of cat I get, nothing will ever fill the hole that Mio left and I just have to live with it forever. And I worry that I just haven’t given our current cats enough time (they are now 15 months old), and maybe they will become more affectionate with time?

I feel like I am just putting myself through the emotional wringer by being on the verge of adopting another cat, going backwards and forwards about it and then backing out, then being disappointed about backing out.

I love all of our cats dearly but I get really upset at times that they basically don’t even like to be pet.

Thank you if you read all of this, sorry for the length.
 

Jayflower

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
816
Purraise
3,574
Location
Illinois
mio-nozawa mio-nozawa Don't worry about any goofy "stigmas" that people have created about having too many cats. If you want to have 5 cats, go for it; if you want to have 10 cats, that's cool too. As long as you're happy and the cats are happy, who cares what anyone else thinks.

As far as finding a cat that has the type of personality that you're looking for, maybe visit some local shelters and interact with some of the cats that they have available for adoption. Maybe you will be able to find one who really loves being petted.
 

jcat

Mo(w)gli's can opener
Veteran
Joined
Feb 13, 2003
Messages
73,213
Purraise
9,851
Location
Mo(w)gli Monster's Lair
If you have 4 cats that get along, you should consider that a fifth might upset the balance, that is, cause fighting among the others.

Fifteen-month-olds are still pretty hyper, so there's a good chance that they'll become cuddlier once they're true adults.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #6

mio-nozawa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 23, 2014
Messages
21
Purraise
17
Location
Austin, TX
Thanks for the advice guys.

I already foster kittens so I am not so worried about my cats not getting along. They
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7

mio-nozawa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 23, 2014
Messages
21
Purraise
17
Location
Austin, TX
Ugh posted before I was ready...

Thanks for the advice guys, I am going to think on it some more.

I already foster kittens so I am not so worried about my cats not getting along. They are really curious about new cats. We currently have 3 fosters in the house since the shelter is completely out of room, but since they are not my cats that I have to look after for the next 20 years, it doesn’t feel the same. Also that’s how I know 1 more cat would be fine, but I don’t think I could do 6 or 7 adult cats!

I also volunteer at the shelter, but the only two cats I’ve seen so far that I really fell in love with were both very old seniors, and it would be super unfair to have adopted them when I have rambunctious young cats.
 
Top