So I have 2 young, healthy cats, and they have both always been on the picky side...or at least my older one has, while the younger one will strangely only eat/copy what the older one approves of. I've always managed to find a rotation of a few brands/flavors that they will eat, but they've been turning their nose up at all of those varieties recently now....after buying full cases, naturally. I've tried a lot of brands in the past that they've refused so I'm running out of ideas. They have dry food that they eat without issue, but I don't want that to make up any more than half of their diet.
Soooo...I need suggestions for more (healthy) options that I haven't tried yet- preferably with no grains, no carageenan, and little to no veggie/fruit fillers
*Foods they started turning their nose up at that they used to love consistently: Nutro natural choice, Whole Earth Farms, Chicken Soup for the Soul, Sheba, Merrick Purrfect Bistro trays
*Foods they loved for about a day or 2, then decided they didn't like- Maybe I should give these another shot? : Soulistic, Weruva, Earthborn Holistic, Fancy Feast classics, Hound & Gatos, Canidae
*Foods I've tried that they hated right away: Tiki Cat, Wild Calling, Merrick Back Country, Evo, Fussie Cat, nature's variety instinct, Merrick LID, and probably others I can't think of.
*Budget can't be higher than what Weruva/tiki cat usually costs so the super premium brands like Feline Natural are out.
Soooo...I need suggestions for more (healthy) options that I haven't tried yet- preferably with no grains, no carageenan, and little to no veggie/fruit fillers
*Foods they started turning their nose up at that they used to love consistently: Nutro natural choice, Whole Earth Farms, Chicken Soup for the Soul, Sheba, Merrick Purrfect Bistro trays
*Foods they loved for about a day or 2, then decided they didn't like- Maybe I should give these another shot? : Soulistic, Weruva, Earthborn Holistic, Fancy Feast classics, Hound & Gatos, Canidae
*Foods I've tried that they hated right away: Tiki Cat, Wild Calling, Merrick Back Country, Evo, Fussie Cat, nature's variety instinct, Merrick LID, and probably others I can't think of.
*Budget can't be higher than what Weruva/tiki cat usually costs so the super premium brands like Feline Natural are out.