- Thread Starter Thread Starter
- #21
I really hate that I read this so long ago, as everything is just a vague memory now. Like I wasn't even sure who David was, and I don't even remember them being high flyers.Both Dannie and David such high flyers,
I agree with your review - and you couldn't possibly get "teary-eyed" because none of it rang true.The description of this book intrigued me the first time I read it, so was happy when it became a book club choice.
It ended up being way different than I expected, as there was only the one incident of a premonition, or whatever that was. So instead of being mystical or magical, it ended up being real and sad and rather depressing.
Oddly, despite Bella’s cancer diagnosis and eventual death, I didn’t get teary-eyed, which is unusual for me. Maybe because I was more focused on what would happen on December 15th.
I was surprised that real December 15th turned out differently than the premonition one, in that Dannie and Aaron were not deeply in love, and probably won’t see each other again. And I was surprised that Dannie and Dr. Shaw ran into each other at the deli, and he showed clear interest in seeing her again.
Maybe because I expected something different, and though not exactly disappointed, I was a little let down that my expectations didn’t happen.
I find it rather difficult to believe that Bella or anybody would really do such a thing.Would someone (Bella in this case) really buy and refurbish an apartment for a friend as that time she didnt know she was going to die.
That just proves what a lasting impression this book had on you!I really hate that I read this so long ago, as everything is just a vague memory now. Like I wasn't even sure who David was, and I don't even remember them being high flyers.
LOL. That not a sign of a positive review to follow, is it.My turn? Before I start, this may have been one of the worst books I've ever actually finished!
That's the thing about this book, the premonition was a great idea for a story, but there just wasn't enough about it after that one chapter.Just one star ! For what could have been a good idea but which sadly failed in its execution.
It's been too long since I read it now, so facts are fading. Which character was Jewish?Props for having a Jewish main character. Minority representation that's not just a side character is important.
My feelings as well.I think I'm not sure of my final verdict. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it.
Though I'm sure it brought up sad memories for you, it's very interesting to read that Bella pushing her best friend away is something that also happens in real life. I'm glad you found that similarity to your own life helpful.The one thing that was helpful to me was the strife between the main character and Bella when Bella had cancer. I had a close friend who passed from cancer and he got rather belligerent at the end and stopped seeing people. It is helpful to know that others go through things like that in similar situations.
I'm glad you read it too, especially since it's not your typical type of book. But, I guess, in one way, that's what a book club is supposed to do, introduce members to books and genres that they wouldn't normally read.Not my type of book, but I'm glad I read it so that I could join together with my fellow Cat Site book readers for this discussion.
Love, as usual, your "stars". And, great news, the site even has icons for you to use when you rate next month's book.If I finish a book, I will most likely give it two stars. stars.
Both Dannie and David. It was just a nice touch. Usually the main character is your average WASP, and the religious, racial, etc minorities are all side characters.It's been too long since I read it now, so facts are fading. Which character was Jewish?
Thanks. I guess I do vaguely remember that.Both Dannie and David. It was just a nice touch.
A nice touch? I saw it as another frustrating piece of information - Dannie was happy that David was also Jewish - but no reasons given and "Jewish" could easily have been substituted by the words "Catholic", "Moslem", "Hindu", "white", "base-ball player" or even "easy-going" which at least was confirmed by his behaviour!Both Dannie and David. It was just a nice touch. Usually the main character is your average WASP, and the religious, racial, etc minorities are all side characters.