Can I use my cats maternal instinct to introduce a kitten when she doesn't accept older cats?

Should I get a kitten

  • Yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

Saphir21

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jan 31, 2022
Messages
3
Purraise
1
Ok, backstory is kinda long, but I hope it makes sense!

I've had my cat Finnie since I was about 12 y/o, so for almost 9 years now. She was only a few months when I got her, so I'm all she really knows since I was her main person. She's fine with other humans, but she will not allow another cat near her.
Now, that wasn't an enourmous issue when I still lived at my parents, but now I live on my own and work 8 hours a day, during which she's alone, and I feel so bad about it.

I've tried socialising her to cats her age multiple times (at my parents place still, I had the luxury of my siblings getting their own cats on different stories of the house which can be seperated, so we had multiple cats, but Finnie was never able to be with any of them)

I tried a lot of things, but she lived 9 years without other cats, she doesn't accept them

Now, the ecxeption to this are the kittens she had when she was younger (a litter at abt 1 and 3 or 4 years old). She still has that maternal instinct, considering I can't watch kitten videos without her coming to search for them.

So, I was wondering if I could use that. My brothers cat is likely gonna have a litter soon, and maybe I could take one and introduce Finnie to it, see if she accepts it.

This comes with a few drawbacks, ofc. It would probably be risky since Finnie won't recognize the smell, and I'd have to hand raise it since Finnie doesn't produce milk. Idk if she would take over the cleaning/licking it to stimulate digestion, so I might have to do that, too.

Also, I don't know if a young kitten would make sense as company for a 9 year old cat, even tho Finnie is still pretty active. I can't get two kittens to play together either since my landlord doesn't want that many cats in the house...

Overall, I'm conflicted. If it would work, Finnie wouldn't be alone so much of the day, which would be amazing, but would it stress her out more than help?

I would have the option to give the kitten back to my family with their giant house, tho once it comes to that point, we might have to hand raise it regardless because their cat hasn't had kittens before, and She's young, so who knows if she'd take it back...

Is there anything I'm missing? I am aware of the commitment a kitten would be, taking off time of work to feed it regularly, I'd socialise them this time around so I wouldn't have this issue anymore once Finnie is gone and I want another cat, and the 2 decades I might have them around.

Input would be greatly appreciated, I'm just trying to find a good solution for Finnie. If this idea is garbadge, please say so politely, this isn't something I found a lot of info on online since the scenario is pretty specific...
 

StefanZ

Advisor
Staff Member
Advisor
Joined
Sep 18, 2005
Messages
26,101
Purraise
10,807
Location
Sweden
Now, as you DO have a plan B, on what to do IF it doesnt work out, I would say, go ahead and try.

The only question is, if it really needs to be an infant, or if she would be OK with a kitten of say, 8 weeks.

Anyways, essentially you can adopt almost any infant, say from a shelter needing foster help. Or from a rescue group. But this Plan B isnt that handy...
Unless the shelter is OK with taking the kitten back if it doesnt work out. They usually are; because its the handraising phase which is most difficult. A weaned kitten is easier to find adoption homes for.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4

Saphir21

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jan 31, 2022
Messages
3
Purraise
1
Now, as you DO have a plan B, on what to do IF it doesnt work out, I would say, go ahead and try.

The only question is, if it really needs to be an infant, or if she would be OK with a kitten of say, 8 weeks.

Anyways, essentially you can adopt almost any infant, say from a shelter needing foster help. Or from a rescue group. But this Plan B isnt that handy...
Unless the shelter is OK with taking the kitten back if it doesnt work out. They usually are; because its the handraising phase which is most difficult. A weaned kitten is easier to find adoption homes for.
First of all, thank you for the non-judgemental reply, other forums have really made me out to be some kind of monster for even considering this, when all I want is to do something good for the one friend I've had growing up.

My siblings had a younger kitten at some point, not sure of the exact age, but that didn't work out either, sadly.

I've thought about shelters, but stray cats are really not that much of an issue in my area. There is a few, but most are fixed, and the few motherless kittens there are quickly go to people who are already experienced.

I wish fostering cats was an option for me, it would be a much preferred option honestly as I prefer older cats, and that way maybe I could find a cat whos personality works for Finnie...

Sorry, I'm rambling. If I'm honest, I'm probably not gonna try due to the risks, it's just on my mind because I keep feeling guilty for raising Finnie alone in my 12 year old ignorance and wrong teachings from my parents, and I just wish I could take all that time back and give her a cat to be social with so she's not alone whenever I'm gone
 

Joelle and the kittens

TCS Member
Adult Cat
Joined
Jun 4, 2021
Messages
190
Purraise
250
Location
New Jersey
I don't think she's feeling lonely, especially not in the sense that humans feel. Some cats do have attachment issues where they get upset when left alone, but if she hasn't shown any behavioral issues before (like you come home to the room trashed, or neighbors complain of her crying constantly) then she probably isn't bothered by the solitude. Most cats will just sleep throughout the day even when there are other cats around.
I do hope your brother's cat and kittens get fixed as soon as possible, though. Pregnancies increase chances of many cancers and pyometria, and in general the stress has detrimental effects on lifespan/healthspan.
 

Sarthur2

Cat lady extraordinaire
Staff Member
Advisor
Joined
Mar 8, 2015
Messages
36,091
Purraise
17,887
Location
Sunny Florida
I would not take a newborn from its mom and siblings. Kittens need to stay with their moms for 8-12 weeks ideally.

Should you get a kitten, your cat would adjust over time, but as others have pointed out, she sounds like she’s doing just fine on her own.
 
Top