Your Favorite Past American Idol?

Who is your favorite past Idol?

My favorite definately has to be Carrie Underwood - I think she's incredibly talented. Her 1st CD that came out this year is great!

I also really like Kelly Clarkson.

Who has been your favorite past American Idol?

Can I vote for Chris?

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

Can I vote for Chris?

Click to expand...

Yes, yes you can

I say Chris AND Kelly Clarkson...I love her!!

Mine is Carrie Underwood I had her song at hubbys funeral.....

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

Can I vote for Chris?

Click to expand...

Can I vote for Josh Gracin?

Of the winners, definitely Kelly. Of non-winners, Chris has my vote!!!

Originally Posted by goosehazel

Can I vote for Josh Gracin?

Click to expand...

Man he can sing and shake it a hot one

Originally Posted by valanhb

Of non-winners, Chris has my vote!!!

Click to expand...

Mine too!

Of the winners I like Kelly and Carrie my favorite non winner is Chris by a mile!! he is so hot!
THey had to tease us with him last night too!!

Can I vote for Bo Bice

I haven't really liked any of the winners. I can almost understand some of the ones that won, but am still shaking my head over Fantasia. YUCK!

Fantasia hasn't really made much of her winning American Idol either. I know she is making that movie about her life that is for Lifetime but she hasn't done anything musically has she?

Originally Posted by Phenomsmom

Fantasia hasn't really made much of her winning American Idol either. I know she is making that movie about her life that is for Lifetime but she hasn't done anything musically has she?

Click to expand...

I agree - her and Ruben both haven't really done anything with their music careers - have they?

I don't know how Ruben won. He had I think 2 songs out and I didn't like them. That I'm sorry 2004? What was that about!!

Your right - that was a bad song

Carrie Underwood. Kelly Clarkson is alright, but I prefer Carrie.

You know, I really liked Rueben when he was on the show........although I thought Clay deserved to win.........too bad he's not around much anymore.

Originally Posted by kittylover4ever

You know, I really liked Rueben when he was on the show........although I thought Clay deserved to win.........too bad he's not around much anymore.

Click to expand...

Clay sounded GREAT last night on AI!

What was the name of the song he sang?

I think I heard that Ruben was actuallly dropped from his contract. I know Fantasia's record sales weren't very good either. Both of them have really faded into oblivion. Guess that just goes to show - just winning Idol isn't enough to make you a star. Kelly and Carrie both have good careers ahead of them though.