Who is going to watch American Idol tonight?

Another 2 hour show? YAY!

Tuesdays are full of good shows - ANTM, AI and Real World! Good thing I don't have anything going on tonight!

I hope that they all pick good songs tonight!

The song rumors I heard are certainly wrong!

Is it a good show tonight?
When you can...tell us who you think were the best 3.

Ok East Coasters...I'm on the West Coast, was AI good tonight?

Actually, I was pleasantly surprised with how good it was.

OMG, Chris is amazing. End of story, he is simply amazing.

And even more surprising, I didn't think Kevin was the worst tonight.

I didn't either. Lisa was the worst, I think. Bucky wasn't good, and neiither was Taylor (whome I really like).
I think they will be the bottom 3.

Overall, they did a lot better than they did last week. Last week STUNK!

Originally Posted by valanhb

Actually, I was pleasantly surprised with how good it was.

OMG, Chris is amazing. End of story, he is simply amazing.

And even more surprising, I didn't think Kevin was the worst tonight.

Click to expand...

Yeah chris did a great job....i think buckey is going tomorrow based on the performance last night...but i really want kevin to go....he was also very bad!!

The show much much better last night than last week.

Heidi, I agree! Kevin wasn't the worst

My bottom 2 are Bucky and Lisa with Bucky being the worst. Lisa did OK, but she was blah. I do not know who else I would add at the bottom. Overall, they all did pretty well.

I thought Taylor was awful, terrible song, terrible "dance" moves, just not good. Mandisa and Katherine were amazing. I dont care if Katherine ever gets booted, Im still buying her first CD. As much as I dont care for Kevin, I thought he did really well last night. Bucky also wasnt too good. Kelly was awesome. Hard to tell who is getting voted off though.

Yep I agree too and I can't stand that kid Kevin! He just urks me, the voice is so strange. But Lisa was just blah, nothing special at all. Bucky...hmm, yeah, i think it's time for him to go, just doesn't have it. Ace, sigh, those eyes will keep him in there!
AND Chris ROCKED again! I love how he rearranges his songs, makes them his. Go Chris Go!!

I thought Mandisa was great-I loved that necklace!! I think the bottom three should be Lisa, paris, Bucky or Kevin. That version of Walk the Line (well I just bought a Johnny Cash CD yesterday!!) well you would never know the lyrics were that old!!! I think Barry Manilow did a great job working with everyone.

I missed Paris's performance!! I just don't think Bucky did a good job and Lisa was just ok. I am even worried about Taylor. I didn't like the song, I felt it was too repetitive. I know that the judges liked Aces performance but I didn't like it. He is a very good piece of eye candy!!!

I LOVED Chris last night!!! Along with Katherine, Mandisa and Kelly!!!! I thought they did a fabulous job!!!

I won't talk about Kevin!

Mandissa blew me away, she is so talented (I loved her necklace too Gail!). I thought she was the best one last night, IMO

Taylor, Kevin & Bucky were my bottom three last night - I don't care for them in the first place - but Taylors preformace was just awful!

Kathrine was amazing too, she is so very talented, I'm glad that Simon said that he thought she would be in the top 3! I'll definately be buying her first CD too, even if she doesn't win!

Chris... he is just gorgeous! He did a great job too!

I wasn't blown away by Katherine last night. It sounded "forced" to me. It was still good, but I don't think it was her best performance. Mandisa is a great talent, and I really hope that America can get over the idea that the Idol has to be thin. I think she should definitely be in the last 3.

Earl is in the music industry (he produces a syndicated radio show) and HATES AI with a passion. But I made him come out and listen to the recap of Chris since he does work in the rock scene. Even he said "He's going to go far." And he thought that Kevin is "so gone", and so was Taylor and Lisa (He didn't see Bucky's recap). He thought Ace was good, and could see Kelly going a long way in Country.

I think Lisa is going to be going home, since she was in the bottom 3 and gave nothing in her performance to save her. I thought it sounded like the performances at the amusement park in the summer - outfit and all.

I absolutely ADORE Elliott's voice. I hope America has enough musical knowledge to see that he can sing and vote accordingly. He doesn't have the "dog and pony" show like some of the other contestants but his voice is just heaven sent and he has TRUE vocal talent.

Bucky and Lisa were the worst ones last night.

I bet anything they will be the lowest.

Originally Posted by lovemycodygirl

Yep I agree too and I can't stand that kid Kevin! He just urks me, the voice is so strange. But Lisa was just blah, nothing special at all. Bucky...hmm, yeah, i think it's time for him to go, just doesn't have it. Ace, sigh, those eyes will keep him in there!
AND Chris ROCKED again!

I love how he rearranges his songs, makes them his. Go Chris Go!!

Click to expand...

Poor Chicken Little!!!!!!!!!!!!

The sky has fallen....

Originally Posted by Taurus77

Poor Chicken Little!!!!!!!!!!!!

Click to expand...

All I can say is this: