Who is going to watch American Idol tonight?

I don't particularly care for Kevin, but like Paula said...I found myself smiling when I watched him perform. I don't know why, but I did. I don't think he'll make it too far in the competition and may be voted off next week, but he's cute and funny and that's what is keeping him in.

Who does everyone think will get voted off next week, based on their performances so far.


Girls: Kinnik and Melissa

Boys: Kevin and Will

I totally agreed with the four that went home. Especially Brenna!

What did everyone think about the way Paula was acting? Did you think she was on something... or just being weird? Even the news this morning that I was watching speculated that she might have been drinking.

Originally Posted by jeanor

I totally agreed with the four that went home. Especially Brenna!

What did everyone think about the way Paula was acting? Did you think she was on something... or just being weird? Even the news this morning that I was watching speculated that she might have been drinking.

Click to expand...

I agree! Something was definitely up with her...she said some completely bizarre things at very inappropriate times.

Originally Posted by jeanor

I totally agreed with the four that went home. Especially Brenna!

What did everyone think about the way Paula was acting? Did you think she was on something... or just being weird? Even the news this morning that I was watching speculated that she might have been drinking.

Click to expand...

I know , who would sign her after that last night.

Originally Posted by kittylover4ever

Me too Heidi........and there's just something about Kevin......by far not the best singer, but don't you just want to squeeze him!?

Click to expand...

He's definitely got the "smush-ability" factor. I'm guessing 10 and 11 year old girls think he's cute and are keeping him there. That and the "moms" of America who think he's a good kid and want to see him do well even if he isn't the best singer there.

I practically danced around when Brenna left! I hope she fades into oblivion. NO talent, grating personality, and seems like she'd be difficult to work with. Blech.

I really won't miss Sway or the crooner kid either, even though he's a Chicago-area kid, it just wasn't working for me. Seems like a good kid with the potential to have a good life ahead of him, though.

And, once Brenna was gone, either Heather or Kinik would've been fine with me, I think they're both sort of forgettable- don't really stand out for any reason.

Originally Posted by OllyExtra05

I practically danced around when Brenna left! I hope she fades into oblivion.

Click to expand...

Originally Posted by OllyExtra05

I practically danced around when Brenna left!

Click to expand...

My husband and I did high-fives!

I agree....so long Brenna.

Originally Posted by xocats

I agree....so long Brenna.

Click to expand...

I didn't like her at all - too fake for me!

I'm glad she is gone!

What do you guys suppose Breanna will try to do next with her life?

I hope it's something not connected with singing !! Even though she said she supposedly had a record deal

Originally Posted by sandra

I hope it's something not connected with singing

!! Even though she said she supposedly had a record deal

Click to expand...

Who do you think would really sign her!?

I have the right day this week -except I don't really care for the girls this season-bring on the fellas

I, too, was happy Brenna was voted off. After her crack to Simon that he didn't decide but the voters decided, I laughed and laughed that she had the lowest total votes! No one likes Miss Attitude.

Tonight's show was pretty good, I really like Kelly and Mandisa. Kelly is sooo dense tho. She is a real sweetheart. Didn't know what a minx was. LOL

I thought Mandisa and Katherine were the best last night.

Anyone else think Paris just keeps getting worse?

I think the two to go home will be Kinnik and Melissa. There is also an outside chance that Ayla could end up in the bottom two.

Well Karen, I agree on who you think is the best two last night. Mandisa really has a set of pipes on her, doesn't she??? LOL I mean that woman can blow!! Katherine is great too! I like that Kelly Pickler........just something about her........not the best singer but just cute in an innocent kind of way. (wonder if it's an act!?)

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

I thought Mandisa and Katherine were the best last night.

Anyone else think Paris just keeps getting worse?

I think the two to go home will be Kinnik and Melissa. There is also an outside chance that Ayla could end up in the bottom two.

Click to expand...

I totally missed it last night!

Did Paris really do bad? She was one of my favs at the beginning!

Did Kellie do pretty good?

I really do like Madissa - its nice to see someone not so 'sterotypical' up there kicking butt! I think she has an amazing voice, I'd love to see her win!

Initially, I thought that Paris would win...hands down, but she might be to inexperienced to handle the pressure.
So far...I think that Katherine has the most potential.
She has looks, a voice, and is the right age.

Originally Posted by AbbysMom

I thought Mandisa and Katherine were the best last night.

Anyone else think Paris just keeps getting worse?

I think the two to go home will be Kinnik and Melissa. There is also an outside chance that Ayla could end up in the bottom two.

Click to expand...

My thoughts exactly!