I say phooey...to Fooey!

I bought this stuff called Fooey that's supposed to be more bitter than Bitter Apple. I put some on a Q-tip and was getting ready to apply it to my cat's paw (he has a spot on his paw that's taking a long time to heal b/c he keeps licking it) and he licked the Q-tip...then he came back for more! Twice!! Has anybody tried both Fooey and Bitter Apple? I should have gotten the Bitter Apple as well but people kept telling me Fooey was better.

I had gotten a fee sample of Fooey, and didn't wash my hands after applying it to my dog's bandage and ended up tasting it..... It is nasty! So maybe your cat likes strange tastes.