So When I got Gibby, I realized how heavy Molly and especially paige were. so, for the past week, we've been metering their food intake, and feeding twice a day. We only ever leave out enough for 1/2 a serving for each of the three cats, and the morning bowls don't go empty until 9-10 PM. We feed them about 8 AM, and they pretty much don't seem to eat during the day. At night, we give them the same amount, and sometimes a wet supplement of like 1/3 a pouch of wet stuff. Paige I've noticed has lost a bit of weight, However, I thik that's more to do with Gibby playing with her all the time than her food reduction.. So, since they don't seem to be suffering terribly, or missing the food now that they're not free feeding... how did they get so fat int he first place?