Litter Choices

These are the only litter choices I have

Tidy cats

Arm and Hammer

What would you choose out of these brands? Please don't say neither because this is all that's available here.

Well for me, Arm N Hammer was actually the worst litter I've ever tried - it was a sticky mess that stuck to the box and was extremely difficult to scoop for this reason, it tracked everywhere, turned my cats' paws green and had a horrid perfume-y smell - so I'd defintiely go with the other one (but then, I've never tried the other one, so I have no ideas what it's like, and I know there are some people who do like Arm N Hammer).

Are you talking about clumping litter Charcoal? I've tried the Tidy Cats Crystal Blend and right now I use the Arm N Hammer Super Scoop. I definitely think the Arm N Hammer clumps better... smells decent... and controls smells well... and I've never seen my cats have their paws turn green!

Yeah I was referring to the clumping litter. I have no choice but to get one of these. I tried the tidy cats crystal blend one and it makes Char so dusty.. So next time I will try the arm and hammer one.

Originally Posted by pinkdaisy226

Are you talking about clumping litter Charcoal? I've tried the Tidy Cats Crystal Blend and right now I use the Arm N Hammer Super Scoop. I definitely think the Arm N Hammer clumps better... smells decent... and controls smells well... and I've never seen my cats have their paws turn green!

Click to expand...

Yeah, I've heard good things about Arm N Hammer from other people, too, so I'm thinking that maybe it was just the 'formula' I was using - the multicats one? Or else I just got a bad batch? I dunno...

Originally Posted by Juniper

Yeah, I've heard good things about Arm N Hammer from other people, too, so I'm thinking that maybe it was just the 'formula' I was using - the multicats one? Or else I just got a bad batch? I dunno...

Click to expand...

I used A&H for Multiple cats and had the same problems as you did so I assume it's just the formula.

Back to the original post - I've tried every litter known to man and so far I've had really good success with the regular A&H formula (scented or unscented).

Thanks everyone.

Wow I was thinking about looking into the multi-cats formula now that I have 2 cats... I'll definitely cross that out!

I REPULSE ARM & HAMMER! It's great for anything BUT cat litter. Im a dedicatd devoted 100% supported of Tidy Cat (the blue long lasting odor control) it clumps and it controls odor soooooooooooo well. I wont use anything else.

I just started my cats on A&H Easy Flush. It controls odors well, clumps nicely, and it flushes easily. It raises quite a bit of fine dust, which I don't mind as long as my cats use it. As I have the litterbox directly in front of the toilet, the flushability in combination with the ordinary litter price makes it a very attractive option.

I've never used Arm and Hammer, but I do use Tidy Cats Mutiple Cat Scoopable. Tidy Cats isn't the best at clumping, but it is the lowest in dust, and it does smell the best.