My daughter found a stray cat and will never take an animal to the Humane Society again

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Hi everyone,

Long story coming, please bear with me! Has anyone else had any bad experiences with their local humane society?

On Monday, my daughter and her boyfriend found a stray cat on the porch of her boyfriend's off campus apartment. They were told by a neighbor that the cat belonged to another neighbor, but the second neighbor said the cat wasn't hers but had been living on her porch for the last few weeks. The cat was very thin but friendly and non-aggressive. I thought that she had been a house cat. They called me for advice, so I told them to get a box and line it with an old blanket or towel and leave some water, and they could take it to the local humane society in the morning. One of them was putting water out and the cat dashed inside and made herself at home, literally. I have pictures of her splayed comfortably on the couch as though she owned the place. 

Needless to say, they both fell in love with this cat, but took it to the humane society the next morning. They were told to call back on Thursday and if the cat was available for adoption they would get priority.

Yesterday afternoon my daughter called me in hysterics. The humane society deemed the cat unadoptable and were going to euthanize her. Her FeLV and FIV tests were negative, but they said that she scratched and tried to bite one of the techs who was trying to perform another test that involved her mouth--I don't know if they were trying to deworm her or what. Something about it didn't sound right, so I called the humane society myself and got pretty much the same story. They also told me that the cat threw up her food the night before and was dehydrated because she hadn't had any water for 2 days. They said she was food aggressive--if the cat is hungry, IMO that's to be expected! When I asked if 1.5 days in a shelter in a stressful environment was enough for them to determine whether or not a cat was adoptable, I was told that they don't have the time or the resources to waste on an animal that wouldn't cooperate. The lack of empathy and compassion from the girl on the phone infuriated me to the point where I texted my daughter to go get the cat. (My daughter lives at home.) My daughter paid no adoption fee even though they did vaccinate her, and will take her to my current vet for an evaluation. 

My daughter arrived with the cat last evening and I'll be quite frank IMO the people at the humane society are idiots. The cat is of course separated from my two resident cats and will remain separated until after her vet appointment, and my other cats so far have displayed nothing but curiosity as to what's on the other side of that door.  They're not upset at the scent of another cat. The new cat hissed initially when one of them got too close to the door, but that subsided in a couple of hours. The cat is very thin and malnourished, but really, very sweet. The first thing she did was drink water and eat. She hasn't thrown up her food and has used the litter box. I went in the room this morning and she was stretched out on a blanket under the desk, relaxed and grooming herself. She came right over to me, meowed, and let me pet her. My daughter got a nuzzle and a leg rubbing. 

I'm not seeing what's so unadpotable about this cat. She's eating and drinking normally, not growling or hissing much less scratching and biting. As long as her vet visit checks out--and I warned my daughter that she needs to be prepared if the cat is not healthy or can't be treated--I think she'll make a great addition. 

My daughter says she will never, ever take another animal to that location again. I'm flabbergasted, too. This cat needs love and affection and a good home. They were ready to just give up on her after only a day and a half and it makes me wonder how many other animals have been needlessly put down there. 
 

shadowsrescue

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Apr 27, 2011
Messages
7,026
Purraise
5,099
Location
Ohio
Welcome to TCS!  Thank you so so much for rescuing this sweet soul.  The world needs more people like you. 

I am sorry you had such an awful and negative experience with the Humane Society.  Maybe a follow up call to the CEO or president/manager is in order.  I know most shelters are overwhelmed and often do not have the resources available to work/socialize all cats.  Yet your experience was not warranted at all.  Fortunately you saved the kitty.

You are doing everything right by keeping the cat separated from your other kitties.  You want the cat vet checked first. 

Thank you for all you have done and sharing your story.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #3

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Thanks for your response. :) I felt so awful for this poor cat. She really is a sweetie and it just blows my mind that the Humane Society of all places would treat an animal that way. The lack of resources I can understand, but not the callousness. These are people who are supposed to love animals, after all. I had both of my other cats spayed by the Humane Society (different county and location) and I didn't have any issues with them then.

I don't even want to think about how many other animals have been needlessly put down at that location--it would be too depressing but you can't rescue them all no matter how much you'd like to. 

The new cat has a vet appointment on Monday so I'll know more then. The tech I spoke to said they probably won't need to do a full blood workup and they'll just give us a treatment plan to address the weight issues. 
 

frajude

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Messages
72
Purraise
12
Where was this Humane Society. I donate to one.
 

Primula

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 1, 2010
Messages
6,838
Purraise
533
Location
Connecticut, USA
I'm not overly fond of the Connecticut Humane Society. I'm sure they do a decent job, but I prefer my own private vet. My husband still uses Fox Memorial, which is a part of the Society. But that's his decision, not mine.
 

msaimee

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 21, 2013
Messages
1,850
Purraise
1,697
Location
Western PA
Thank you so much for saving and adopting this kitty. Unfortunately, many Humane Societies are over crowded and their staff are burnt out and overwhelmed. Many of them do euthanize a lot of cats. I agree that you should call the supervisor of the shelter or CEO or someone and make a complaint. This Kitty will love you and your family for your kindness and will be a source of joy.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Where was this Humane Society. I donate to one.
Hi Frajude,

It's Beaver County, Pennsylvania. I usually take mine to the Western Pennsylvania Humane Society in Pittsburgh for spay/neuter and shots and never had a problem there, but Beaver Co. was only a mile or so away from his house.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #8

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
I'm not overly fond of the Connecticut Humane Society. I'm sure they do a decent job, but I prefer my own private vet. My husband still uses Fox Memorial, which is a part of the Society. But that's his decision, not mine.
Well, from now on it's the WPHS or my private vet. Any more strays go to a no kill shelter.

Update on New Kitty. She's not quite so food aggressive. She seems to realize that she doesn't have to wonder where her next meal is coming from. She's sleeping a lot and very soundly. I'm guessing she's exhausted from having to sleep with one eye open for so long and can finally relax. I just went in to check on her and she stretched and looks pretty comfortable.

Eating, drinking and using the litter box regularly.

She did take a swipe at me yesterday, but no claws, so just a warning.

My daughter who was at a previously scheduled weekend event at school came home and went straight into the cat's room. The cat came right out and plopped herself down on my daughter's lap. Traitor. LOL
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #9

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Oh, one thing I am concerned about. She is breathing very fast. I don't know if it's just anxiety or respiratory. She goes to the vet tomorrow.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #10

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Thank you so much for saving and adopting this kitty. Unfortunately, many Humane Societies are over crowded and their staff are burnt out and overwhelmed. Many of them do euthanize a lot of cats. I agree that you should call the supervisor of the shelter or CEO or someone and make a complaint. This Kitty will love you and your family for your kindness and will be a source of joy.
Thanks. :) She really is a sweetie! Updates as I have them!
 

frajude

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Messages
72
Purraise
12
I am glad it is not in Texas.  Many years ago I had bought a Great Dane puppy.  My circumstances changed and I was forced to move and leave her in a yard with no fence chained.  I would not come home until late at night.  I took he to the Fort Worth Humane Society.  The woman at the desk raised Great Danes and said she was going to adopt her.  The little thing was so scared.  Never really got over that. Sorry you had such a bad experience. 
 

msaimee

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 21, 2013
Messages
1,850
Purraise
1,697
Location
Western PA
Yikes, that is my local Humane Society. And you are correct -- the Western PA shelter is so very much better. Let us know how the vet appt. goes. It sounds like she's settling into her new home very happily :)
 

muffy

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Messages
6,198
Purraise
12,664
Location
Fredericksburg, VA
I'm sorry your daughter had such a bad experience. I had the same experience with my local Humane Society in Southern Maryland. The first year of feeding and caring for my feral colony I had about 22 cats and they just kept having litters. Someone suggested that I call the Humane Society and ask for help. When I called them the lady was down right nasty. She said if they were not tamed I would have to take them to the animal shelter and they would be euthanized the same day I brought them in.  I was so upset I started crying and just hung up on the women after telling her that was not an option. It was after that I found out about TNR and that took care of the problem.

I hope everything works out for your daughter.
 

frajude

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Messages
72
Purraise
12
That is horrible Muffy.  Here in Texas the SPCA and Humane Society as well as Kittico do spay, neuter and release.  Kittico is an independent non profit that neuters animals personal(50.00)  feral free.  I had a woman that lives across the road that was feeding feral cats and they kept breeding.  She called animal control which ended that story.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #15

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Yikes, that is my local Humane Society. And you are correct -- the Western PA shelter is so very much better. Let us know how the vet appt. goes. It sounds like she's settling into her new home very happily
Oh wow,  a local! Go Pens! 

I don't know about happily but every day gets a little better. She still growls at me occasionally, probably because I can't tell the difference between her rumbles and growls yet. She doesn't give my daughter a bit of trouble. 

The vet appointment went very well! She's already gained half a pound and other than a very slight heart murmur and malnutrition, she's in pretty good shape. During her exam, she was fine right up until they tried to scruff her neck--then the claws came out. They can't tell if she's spayed or not because of that. They said to bring her back in a month or so after she's calmed down and they'll try again, and do some blood work to see if anything else is going on. They said it was fine to start integrating her with the resident cats. 

She was so patient during the car ride--she was sitting up just looking around through her carrier. My other two would be squawking bloody murder. 

I put my resident cats in my bedroom last night and let the new cat (my daughter named her Sorin after a video game character) out. She didn't go very far. Just out of the door and into the hallway, where she plopped down and chilled out. But that's okay. I'll do the same tonight and let her get used to having a home again. Within a few weeks we should be good to go, I hope. We do have another challenge coming up. We're moving to a new house at the end of the month. My mother is moving in with us, and she has two cats of her own. They're senior cats (one is so old they don't even know how old she is) and I don't know if they're going to appreciate 3, 4 and 5 year old cats running around. It's not going to be easy, that's for sure. 
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #16

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
 
I'm sorry your daughter had such a bad experience. I had the same experience with my local Humane Society in Southern Maryland. The first year of feeding and caring for my feral colony I had about 22 cats and they just kept having litters. Someone suggested that I call the Humane Society and ask for help. When I called them the lady was down right nasty. She said if they were not tamed I would have to take them to the animal shelter and they would be euthanized the same day I brought them in.  I was so upset I started crying and just hung up on the women after telling her that was not an option. It was after that I found out about TNR and that took care of the problem.

I hope everything works out for your daughter.
Oh that's awful! I don't get it. These are people who are supposed to love animals. The lack of resources I can understand, but not the lack of compassion. 
 

msaimee

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 21, 2013
Messages
1,850
Purraise
1,697
Location
Western PA
Nice to hear from another local. Sorry to say I'm not a sports fan, except for the NY Yankees, which makes me an oddball around here :)

I have a 16 year old orange tabby who has a heart murmur, and he takes everything in stride. Whenever the four young cats in my house get to be too much for him, he goes into a closet to rest. Older cats are generally very patient with other cats. I'm sure all will be well with your crew after some initial excitement --cats are resilient. I'm not surprised your new kitty favors your daughter since she rescued him. He'll never forget that.
 

Primula

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 1, 2010
Messages
6,838
Purraise
533
Location
Connecticut, USA
I have a 16 year old orange tabby who has a heart murmur, and he takes everything in stride. Whenever the four young cats in my house get to be too much for him, he goes into a closet to rest. Older cats are generally very patient with other cats. I'm sure all will be well with your crew after some initial excitement --cats are resilient. I'm not surprised your new kitty favors your daughter since she rescued him. He'll never forget that.
Interesting you say that. My orange tabby died post-surgery this year - most likely of an undiagnosed heart condition. When he was born in my house & his sisters were annoying him he would quietly find a spot to sleep by himself in my sock drawer or a closet. It always greatly amused me when he did this.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #19

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Nice to hear from another local. Sorry to say I'm not a sports fan, except for the NY Yankees, which makes me an oddball around here


I have a 16 year old orange tabby who has a heart murmur, and he takes everything in stride. Whenever the four young cats in my house get to be too much for him, he goes into a closet to rest. Older cats are generally very patient with other cats. I'm sure all will be well with your crew after some initial excitement --cats are resilient. I'm not surprised your new kitty favors your daughter since she rescued him. He'll never forget that.
Apparently not. I let her out when I got home from work yesterday. She went into the living room and the kitchen, sniffed around, then went back to laying in the doorway to her sanctuary and groomed herself. When my daughter came home, we let her out again. She sat next to my daughter on the couch while she was playing a video game. 

When I got home yesterday, one of my resident cats (Itty Bitty Kitty, who is anything but Itty Bitty!) was hiding under my bed and wouldn't come out even with treats. She's usually waiting for me at the door. She's always been very shy and timid but she's a very affectionate cat. It we're going to have a problem, it's going to be with her. When we first got her, she stayed under my bed for almost a month before she got up the nerve to venture out, and she only did that when she thought no one was looking. It took her quite a while to integrate with the then single cat (Magic, a tortie), who was about 8 months old at the time. 

Magic couldn't care less. She sits outside Sorin's room just sniffing around. Not intimidated at all, just curious. 
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #20

woodstock66

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
21
Purraise
2
Location
Western Pennsylvania
Interesting you say that. My orange tabby died post-surgery this year - most likely of an undiagnosed heart condition. When he was born in my house & his sisters were annoying him he would quietly find a spot to sleep by himself in my sock drawer or a closet. It always greatly amused me when he did this.
My two existing cats love closets. 
 
Top