TheCatSite.com › Forums › General Forums › IMO: In My Opinion › Who monitors civil servants?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Who monitors civil servants?

post #1 of 13
Thread Starter 
I am so angry I could spit. I've been married to a German citizen since 1980, and living in Germany on a permanent basis since 1982. I've had a permanent residence permit since 1987. I just got a new passport, and went to the county's immigration office this afternoon to get my residence permit transferred from my old passport to the new one, and to register the new passport number. That was no problem, but the young woman who dealt with everything told me she was in the midst of reviewing my file, because there were some irregularities, and if I hadn't come in, I would've heard from her next week.
The civil servant who was formerly responsible for people whose last names also start with "B" was fired a few months ago (that's serious: civil servants can only be fired for severe misconduct). It seems that he had something against binational marriages, and didn't observe the laws. I got my permanent residence permit in 1987, with the proviso that I couldn't be "self-employed". The guy also insisted that I have a form signed by my "landlord" stating that my home was a certain size (we have owned our house since 1982, so I had to get my husband to sign as my "landlord" - that was bad enough.) In 1993, I was offered a "once-in-a-lifetime" opportunity: I was offered the chance to take over control of a state-accredited private junior college; I had to turn the offer down because that would've meant I was self-employed. Today I was told that the proviso was illegal (it has been removed), the form my husband had to sign was unnecessary, and that as late as 1994, after we'd been married for 14 years, the man had a note saying, "sham marriage?" in my file!!! And I'm not an isolated case. Others are going to sue. I haven't decided what to do. The man has already been fired and has lost his pension benefits; on the other hand, it took his superiors at least 23.5 years to notice they had a xenophobe working in immigration.
post #2 of 13
jcat,

Maybe they are getting even with our xenophobe, Dubya. :-)

Hang in there, all will be well.

Cheers,

Ann, Jim, Miss Kitty and, soon, Samwise, on a Texas beach
post #3 of 13
Geesh! How's that for stimulating immigration. I say you ought to sue... I don't know how much money you may get, but at least that guy isn't going to have an easy time.


BTW, Jcat I know its none of my business, but a thought that has comed through my mind, now that you say your husband is German. Have you considered checking what are the rules of double citizenship in Germany? In some countries one can apply for double citizenship if he/she is married to a national of that country. Then, you would have no problems with residence permits and so on, since technically you are German, and at the same time you don't lose your American citizenship. Just a thought, which I guess may help.
post #4 of 13
Thread Starter 
Dual citizenship is permitted if you marry a citizen of a Middle Eastern country, where child custody automatically goes to the husband. Because I live in Germany, I would have to renounce my U.S. citizenship if I became a German citizen. My citizenship is part of my identity, and I also promised my parents that I wouldn't give it up. My husband and I have also not ruled out the possibility of moving to the U.S. once we retire. I'm very angry, but I have a job I really like, and we get by financially. Other people this man "preyed upon" were deported, or denied the right to bring relatives to this country. On the one hand, I don't want to waste time and money pushing the matter in court; on the other hand, I feel that basic human rights were violated, and the local government did nothing. The young woman I talked to today felt that I should pursue the matter, because I'm a U.S. citizen, and thus have "more rights" than people from the Third World, and because I've been married to a German citizen for over half my life, so the "sham marriage" claim just doesn't cut it.
post #5 of 13
No, I completely understand that you don't want to leave your citizenship... neither would I do so, such an idea is completely out of the question. I just thought that if it was possible, then it could be a nifty option to go through. But if it isn't possible then I agree that we ough to forget that idea.
post #6 of 13
If it was me, I would sue, then donate the money earned toward helping your town. That way, you won't feel like you were getting monetary gain from his ignorance. Depending on the size of the settlement, it could be sponsering a few cages at the local no kill shelter or buying some food and medications, to building a new playground!

Sandy
post #7 of 13
Thread Starter 
I've decided not to litigate - I have enough hassle at the moment. However, I've put together a file of documents outlining this guy's decisions, and how they've affected my professional life. I've also talked to a few possible, and willing, witnesses, regarding the potential financial losses I suffered. (It pays to be a pack rat). I've reached two attorneys representing other victims of this guy's xenophobia, and have appointments with them next week. I'm perfectly willing to testify against him. I doubt that he'll suffer more than he already has (loss of his job and pension benefits), but maybe some judges will take note. That might be too optimistic - Germany officially doesn't apply common law, but statute law. Unfortunately, I feel that "Dubya's" refusal to recognize international law will probably affect the case; thus my decision not to litigate. Another reason for me to advise people not to vote for the guy in November! Quite frankly, anti-American sentiment has, in my lifetime, never been higher than at present. Dubya and his hand-picked cronies (chosen by whom - Cheney, Bush, Sr., Wolfowitz?) have made life extremely difficult for those of us Americans who live outside the U.S. for whatever reason (personal, business, military). He has undermined U.S. credibility to such an extent that any U.S. citizens living abroad may have to feel they have to decry him, in order to be able to live a "normal life".
post #8 of 13
Quote:
Originally posted by jcat
He has undermined U.S. credibility to such an extent that any U.S. citizens living abroad may have to feel they have to decry him, in order to be able to live a "normal life".
jcat,

You are so correct in your observation of the way our administration is commonly viewed overseas, and U.S. nationals are called upon to pay the price. I spent more than 20 years serving my country, first in uniform, then in the U. S. Foreign Service. I am appalled at what Bush has done to the image of our nation and its effectiveness abroad, after all the years and efforts I and others spent trying to develop the opposite image.

Let me give you a very current example of what is happening in your home country. Take a look at this link: http://www.chron.com/cs/CDA/ssistory.mpl/front/2402460

The article in today's Houston Chronicle reports that two U. S. Army intelligence agents crawled the corridors of the University of Texas in an effort to obtain a roster of attendees at a recent student conference on Islamic law and sexism. Back to Nixon and COINTELPRO.

THE U. S. ARMY -- IN AN INSTITUTION OF HIGHER LEARNING -- MONITORING ATTENDANCE AT A UNIVERSITY FUNCTION!! How could you come up with more intimidation of academic freedom?

This is almost too shocking to believe, and, perhaps even more shocking, the article did not even make the first page -- not even the first section of the newspaper. This suggests to me that our people are becoming accustomed to these blatant assaults on our personal liberties, and the press just takes them in its stride.

Things could be worse for you with bureaucrats. Here at home you might have had military personnel crawling around investigating you for doing something our constitution declares to be your right.

We wish you all the best,

Jim, Ann, Miss Kitty, and soon, Samwise, from a Texas beach
post #9 of 13
Thread Starter 
Jim, I just read the article - what an outrage! Is the US trying to fill the "void" left by the former Eastern Bloc? Is this going to eventually lead to another Kent State? I know that phone calls here in Germany have been "monitored", or at least "spot checked", for decades by U.S. intelligence services. There was never any secret about it. I have to assume that any "anti-Bush" posts on a site such as this might also attract attention.
I just got off the phone with my mom, who is extremely anti-Bush. She was describing him as a little boy playing soldier-king. Apparently he and his cronies also like to play cloaks and daggers. Obviously, after 9-11 vigilance is called for, but within reason! I think she'll decide to come live with us if he is re-elected.
post #10 of 13
Quote:
Originally posted by jcat
I think she'll decide to come live with us if he is re-elected.
jcat,

If you are an aficionado of Tolkien, or have viewed the Lord of the Rings movie cycle, you will recognize the name of the newest member of our family here on the beach. After seeing the marvelous scenery in the movies, we are tempted to go to New Zealand if Dubya is reelected, and take Samwise home with us. :-)

We understand that there are fine beaches there too.

It's really not funny, is it??

All the best, from

Jim, Ann, Miss Kitty and, soon, Samwise, on a Texas beach
post #11 of 13
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally posted by James Brown
jcat,

If you are an aficionado of Tolkien, or have viewed the Lord of the Rings movie cycle, you will recognize the name of the newest member of our family here on the beach. After seeing the marvelous scenery in the movies, we are tempted to go to New Zealand if Dubya is reelected, and take Samwise home with us. :-)

We understand that there are fine beaches there too.

It's really not funny, is it??

All the best, from

Jim, Ann, Miss Kitty and, soon, Samwise, on a Texas beach
I laugh at the thought of my 72-year-old, monolingual, ailing mother, until a few years ago a Republican party member, who has always worried about me living in a foreign country, packing her bags and her two rather large dogs and cat and moving here because she can't bear to see what is happening to her homeland - yes, it's not funny.
post #12 of 13
Look, if that crazy cowboy gets reelected, I seriously think we will get the h*** outta here. But it isn't that much of a problem, as here getting out of the country means a quickie 40 minute flight to the Dominican Republic. And conditions are better there than in P.R. (and the anexionists say that without the Americans governing Puerto Rico we would be dying of hunger).
post #13 of 13
Quote:
Originally posted by James Brown
jcat,

If you are an aficionado of Tolkien, or have viewed the Lord of the Rings movie cycle, you will recognize the name of the newest member of our family here on the beach. After seeing the marvelous scenery in the movies, we are tempted to go to New Zealand if Dubya is reelected, and take Samwise home with us. :-)

We understand that there are fine beaches there too.

It's really not funny, is it??

All the best, from

Jim, Ann, Miss Kitty and, soon, Samwise, on a Texas beach
Ooo yes NZ beaches are awsome!

Sorry to go O/T but I had to agree with you.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: IMO: In My Opinion
TheCatSite.com › Forums › General Forums › IMO: In My Opinion › Who monitors civil servants?