Lost two cats to HCM in 3 yrs, heartbroken and so many questions

kimawalter

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
8
Purraise
1
My boyfriend and I got two kittens in mid-2012 -- our first pets (as adults). Kima was a DSH girl from the shelter. Walter was a Devon Rex boy from a breeder in a neighboring state.

Kima died suddenly without any obvious warning signs in January 2013, at 10 months old. The vet who examined her body (we did not have an autopsy) said it was likely a sudden death from hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. It was devastating to lose our kitten, and I didn't recover for a long time. She was a sweet girl with so many adorable quirks.


After she died, Walter was extremely lonely. It was hard to think about adopting another cat right away, but he really needed a companion.

So we adopted a brown tabby from a different shelter in February 2013, and named her Penelope. We tried to separate the cats for a slow introduction, but Walter rushed the gates. Here they are a few hours after we brought her home (Penelope on left):


A couple of weeks ago, Walter wasn't acting like himself and had labored breathing, so we took him to the ER. After X-rays and an echocardiogram, the cardiologist told us Walter had severe HCM and was in congestive heart failure. He also had a small blood clot in his heart.

He spent three days in the hospital getting oxygen and figuring out the right mix of medications (his kidneys didn't react well to one of them, I think atenolol). We brought him home on a Friday. His breathing stayed at 45-60/minute all weekend, he didn't want to eat, was incontinent at one point and extremely weak. We tried extra Lasix and an appetite stimulant, after conferring with the cardiologist.

We said goodbye to our little dude that Sunday evening -- Easter Sunday -- at home, with help from a vet who does house-call euthanasia. He was almost 4 years old.


(I treasure this photo my boyfriend took that day. When I look at it, I can feel Walter clinging to my shoulder like he used to, and his little head burrowing.)

It was the hardest decision we've ever made, to put him to sleep. He perked up a little on Sunday afternoon, and I begged my boyfriend to give it one more day. I think I'll always wonder "what if we'd waited just a little longer? Would he have gotten better?," but at this point I think we made the best choice under the circumstances. My kitty-mom intuition said he WAS going to improve; he'd started purring and looking around and even licked at some wet food right before the vet arrived to put him to sleep. But we never would have forgiven ourselves if the opposite happened and he deteriorated and was miserable, or if he died in pain after throwing a clot. That was our biggest fear. And when I picked him up, I could hear how hard he was straining to breathe and feel how weak he was.

Since he died, I've been in agony. He was the world to me. I keep thinking this is just like the nightmares I used to have about him running away or dying, and I will wake up in the morning and he'll be there in the crook of my arm, and I can wipe my tears and squeeze him because everything is back to normal.

I know this will get easier. I wish I could fast-forward to that part. It's also hard to want to move on, because that requires accepting he's gone.

Penelope is doing fine. I think she might like being the only cat? As sweet as Walter was, he did bully her. He'd also seek her out to curl up with, and then they'd bathe each other -- but I don't remember her ever seeking him out.

************************

I have a lot of questions. If anyone can help answer, I would really appreciate it. I know this is super long...

How can I tell if Penelope is lonely, and if we should get another cat? Are there signs I should be watching for? She seems happy but does wander around yowling sometimes. (That's not really a new thing, though.)

Since we've had two young cats die of HCM, I can't help but feel like we're bad luck for our babies, or we're doing something wrong. (For the record, our cats are kept indoors -- or in Walter's case allowed out for walks on a leash -- fed high-quality food and get check-ups and vaccinations.) I think we'll want another Devon someday, but I'm scared to have my heart broken again if they die young. Does this feeling go away? Are we causing this? The vets said our kitties died because of congenital problems, not something we could control. But I can't help feeling responsible. I'm also scared of Penelope dying now.

What obligations does Walter's breeder have? What obligations do I have? I told her about Walter's diagnosis and death. I asked her to please tell the people who have his siblings, so they can get scans and hopefully catch it early if they have HCM as well. She said she would. She also said Walter's parents' scans have never shown HCM. But from what I've read, genetically, one of them is a carrier, right? And something like half of Walter's siblings are at risk? She's never given me cause not to trust her -- she really seems to care about the cats -- but is there any way to make sure another family won't have to go through this, if for some reason she doesn't tell people?

Do breeders usually just apologize when a young cat dies of HCM? Our contract has the typical health guarantee -- free of congenital defects, kittens are guaranteed up to a year (which seems contradictory). Our breeder was sympathetic about Walter's death, but a part of me is furious. And I'm ... offended, I guess? ... that she didn't offer a refund or another kitten from different parents. I don't even know if we would accept -- but it bothered me that she didn't at least offer. We thought Walter would be in our family for more than just a fraction of the typical feline lifespan. We'd looked forward to Walter cuddling up with our first baby, and now we'll never see that. Sorry isn't enough. (Of course, nothing would fix it, short of Walter still being alive, so maybe this isn't fair.)

Thank you if you read this. After Kima died, I couldn't bring myself to post here but I read through some of your Rainbow Bridge posts because it helped me cope, for some reason. It's wonderful that there is a place where It's OK to mourn your lost fur-child, best friend, sidekick...
 

sprin

TCS Member
Adult Cat
Joined
Mar 15, 2016
Messages
139
Purraise
37
I'm so sorry for your losses! 
Losing a cat young is so hard, especially when you're already dreaming of your future with them. You sound like great cat owners; you gave them the best life that they could have had. I think I would just wait it out with Penelope. It sounds like she doesn't particularly need another companion, so you can go ahead and heal before considering getting another cat. I'm not sure about the breeder question.
 

di and bob

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
16,658
Purraise
23,088
Location
Nebraska, USA
  It sounds like it MAY be a genetic problem, is there any way of checking to see if more of this happened with other kittens from that line? You may want to insist on seeing the scans performed to check for this condition or you will inform the Licensing bureau of your problems.  It may at least alert them to watch for a trend from this breeder. Maybe you can first check with the breeders vet and get their advise? Or ask yours? You could most likely inquire about a new kitten, or insist on one, from a totally different genetic line.  Or go to a totally different breeder. The distraction of a new kitten in your life is welcome after so much pain, your heart is big enough to include him, and the two who went before him would be comforted knowing their legacy of love is being passed on.

  As for Penelope, her routine has been changed, and she surely grieves for the loss of her companion, Time and lots of love and attention will get her through this, mother cats grieve for about two weeks after their kittens leave, so watch her and let her know you understand her pain.   

   A double tragedy like this is truly heartbreaking, my prayers and my heart go out to you. There is absolutely NO reason for you to blame yourself in any way, there is absolutely no way you can predict or control a genetic or inherited problem in a young, seemingly healthy cat. I cry for your pain, but am so thankful that those two found such a wonderful home and so much love in their short lives, you all deserved so much more. I don't blame you for feeling somewhat paranoid now, but don't let it close your heart to the love and happiness that future little souls can bring to your life. All we can do is love them and care for them while we are on this earth, there is no way to predict how long we are able to do this. Both of your sweet babies will want you to remember them with happiness, not pain and tears, although we do have to grieve at the beginning for the loss and the pain in our hearts. The bond you formed will remain in your heart forever, rejoice that you had them in your life at all, they brought you love and sunshine for a while on your life's journey, bless you for your pain from loving so much. I'll pray for you all, take care.......... RIP sweet Kima and Walter you will be remembered and loved forever, and held in loving hearts!
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5

kimawalter

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
8
Purraise
1
 
I'm so sorry for your losses! 
Losing a cat young is so hard, especially when you're already dreaming of your future with them. You sound like great cat owners; you gave them the best life that they could have had. I think I would just wait it out with Penelope. It sounds like she doesn't particularly need another companion, so you can go ahead and heal before considering getting another cat. I'm not sure about the breeder question.
Thank you for the advice on Penelope. I think you're right, we don't need to be thinking about another cat just yet. We'll wait and see how we feel after we're a bit more healed from the loss.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7

kimawalter

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
8
Purraise
1
 
  It sounds like it MAY be a genetic problem, is there any way of checking to see if more of this happened with other kittens from that line? You may want to insist on seeing the scans performed to check for this condition or you will inform the Licensing bureau of your problems.  It may at least alert them to watch for a trend from this breeder. Maybe you can first check with the breeders vet and get their advise? Or ask yours? You could most likely inquire about a new kitten, or insist on one, from a totally different genetic line.  Or go to a totally different breeder. The distraction of a new kitten in your life is welcome after so much pain, your heart is big enough to include him, and the two who went before him would be comforted knowing their legacy of love is being passed on.

  As for Penelope, her routine has been changed, and she surely grieves for the loss of her companion, Time and lots of love and attention will get her through this, mother cats grieve for about two weeks after their kittens leave, so watch her and let her know you understand her pain.   

   A double tragedy like this is truly heartbreaking, my prayers and my heart go out to you. There is absolutely NO reason for you to blame yourself in any way, there is absolutely no way you can predict or control a genetic or inherited problem in a young, seemingly healthy cat. I cry for your pain, but am so thankful that those two found such a wonderful home and so much love in their short lives, you all deserved so much more. I don't blame you for feeling somewhat paranoid now, but don't let it close your heart to the love and happiness that future little souls can bring to your life. All we can do is love them and care for them while we are on this earth, there is no way to predict how long we are able to do this. Both of your sweet babies will want you to remember them with happiness, not pain and tears, although we do have to grieve at the beginning for the loss and the pain in our hearts. The bond you formed will remain in your heart forever, rejoice that you had them in your life at all, they brought you love and sunshine for a while on your life's journey, bless you for your pain from loving so much. I'll pray for you all, take care.......... RIP sweet Kima and Walter you will be remembered and loved forever, and held in loving hearts!
Thank you so much for the reassurance. The cardiologist sent us a card saying we did all we could to save Walter., too (He won over everyone in the hospital while he was there. He was such a charming, intelligent, affectionate and active little guy. My mom told me he was more like a toddler than a cat!) I like what you say about the bond never disappearing. And not closing my heart to future loves. This is a good attitude and perspective, I'm going to keep it in mind.

As for the breeder, we don't have any licensing or enforcement for breeders in the state where we live, or where the breeder lives, at least as of now. Maybe I'll ask her for a confirmation that she has notified the other parents. I feel like I have an ethical responsibility, since I know there is a big risk to Walter's siblings, to make sure they know about this. I'm just not sure how to carry out that responsibility -- especially since I don't have any reason to suspect she won't keep her word.

Are there organizations that keep track of HCM in breeding lines or something like that? It seems like that would be a good way to curb propagation of the gene...
 

di and bob

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
16,658
Purraise
23,088
Location
Nebraska, USA
If the kittens are registered at all as purebreds then there should be a licensing association to lodge a complaint. I know there is with the AKC for dogs, we had a breeder who the club refused to register any more puppies from a particular line when we lodged a complaint against them for a genetic problem in a yorkie puppy we had that died. We were the 'straw' that broke the camel's back. If you have no papers, then your kitten was not registered. I would think you could still lodge a complaint with your local consumer protection office or state regulatory agency, you paid for something that was found to be not as represented, healthy and free of genetic 'defects', (sorry, that is a horrible way to describe this tragic situation). If they can't help you, you might ask them to start keeping track of other complaints so that they can get enough evidence. I would contact your local humane society and make them aware of it too. If it gets to be a known genetic problem the HSUS can step in and prevent the breeder from selling any more from that line. I'm so sorry for your heartache. I urge you to do good things in your babies names, donate your time or supplies to your local shelter, give your time there to give attention to those lost souls that need every bit of love they can get, it really does help with the grieving process. Keep us posted!
 

jcat

Mo(w)gli's can opener
Veteran
Joined
Feb 13, 2003
Messages
73,213
Purraise
9,851
Location
Mo(w)gli Monster's Lair
HCM is a cruel disease, and it's horrible that you've been through the experience not once, but twice. My heart goes out to you.
 

kayleemarie90

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Jun 20, 2016
Messages
15
Purraise
1
Location
Des Moines, IA
Just wanted to say I am really sorry for your losses. I have had so many questions myself about HCM and I had an echocardiogram done on my cat as well and they said likely diagnosis for him is HCM as well and no signs of Congestive Heart Failure as of now. The thing I cannot understand is how often I have heard how common this is now that I have an animal who unfortunately has this and yet I have never heard of such a thing. It all started out with him being lethargic, not eating or drinking and using the bathroom which they ended up finding that he had crystals in his urine so I assumed this was the case and yet he still remained in this state. They ended up saying he had a grade 4 heart murmur and when I did an x-ray he had fluid build up and was perscribed lasix .As of now he is his usual happy self but I fear the outcome will be progressive and eventually fatal and my heart breaks knowing his heart is breaking too. I feel bad when I came across your story of losing more than one cat to this horrible disease and just wanted to say I hope things get better for you and any future kitties you decide to adopt.
 
Top