Wondering if the cat foods I buy are good for them

chalupa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Alpha Cat
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
322
Purraise
30
Location
Chicago
Read an email from Wysong they got me wondering. Can't really afford Wysong foods although I'm on their mailing list. Was reading what he wrote about human grade pet food.
My cats get half cheap friskies pate in the big cans and also some other brands and proteins that are higher priced like mostly Fussie cat, little weruva, some other brands along the same lines. I buy those too because it's the only brands my local independent pet store carries and I prefer the paper litter they order for me. Also pick up a few purina beyond gravy foods at grocery store for them. They get some dry in their diet as well. Some iams hairball, Fromm, but only in small amounts. Diet is mostly wet. So was wondering, is friskies cheap can food the healthiest food my cats are eating? By the way, no raw food is allowed in my house, have a cat intolerant to all forms raw and there is always vomit without fail. Can anyone recommend a good quality cat food that is not owned by purina or any other big companies with organ meat? I remember murr seemed good but pet store stopped carrying it.
What do you think? Here is the article:
TRUTH 41: HUMAN GRADE EQUALS POOR NUTRITION
Dr. Wysong

Spurred on by horror stories about how pet foods contain road kill and euthanized pets, by-products, fillers and the like, the trend in pet foods is "human grade" ingredients.

There are several reasons to steer clear of this claim.

First, human grade can mean Coca Cola, marshmallows, French fries, Jolly Ranchers, and thick crust pizza. The term encompasses the four white poisons of white flour, white oil, white salt, and white sugar. Human grade ingredients are responsible for the epidemic of chronic degenerative diseases plaguing modern humans. So why visit the same results on our trusting pets?

Secondly, although "human grade" has an evocative ring, it has nothing to do with nutrition and health. It is merely marketing without conscience. Watch what primitive humans and carnivores eat in the wild. None of it is "human grade." Many things we now call by-products and non-human grade were the prized fare of our ancestors and our pet's ancestors. Don't judge an ingredient by its word cover. Your pet will do far better eating things like intestines, bones, bruised meat, organs, and rice bran than "human grade" pure white chicken breast and fluffy white flour. The natural archetypal model is what should be followed, not beguiling claims about "human grade" wholesomeness, and steam-cleaned purity.

And a final thought. What should become of all the nutritious "non-human grade" ingredients that are "by-products" of the human food supply chain? Do we just fill landfills with them so we can feed our pets more cosmetically pleasing, human grade, nutrient impoverished, "human grade," white meat and trimmed steaks? Further, this waste would mean that even more food animals would need to be raised and slaughtered. Doing such beyond what is necessary is cruelty to them and to the earth for the environmental toll taken.

Feed your dog and cat using reason, not emotionally charged human invented words like "human grade."
 
Last edited:

2cats4me

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 5, 2014
Messages
2,046
Purraise
211
Wow , that is a lot of info to process but I will I reply as best I can ..  I think the best food for your cats are the foods they will eat and do well on .  Although I have nothing against Purina  my cats cannot eat their products . They like the kibble & FF ( only wet they would eat )  but after  several bouts of occasional vomiting  & diarrhea I decided to stop feeding it .It is NOT good food for my babies . My cats eat Blackwood Grain Free Chicken Meal Dry  & Fromm Four Star Grain Free Salmon Tunachovy Dry .. Both of these products are made by family owned companies .  I believe the best you can do for your cat is feed the best quality  YOU can afford and of course something the cats will eat .  If you buy the so called " Best food there is " it is useless if your cat won't eat it ..  I hope this helps ..
 

siamiam2

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
434
Purraise
23
I'm half with you 2cats. But? Annabel doesn't do well on FF. 3oz?? Yikes. Friskies surf and turf amazingly keeps her thyroid in check. Go figure.[emoji]128518[/emoji] I'd love to put her on Iams or Beyond but don't have the money for research yet. I think any cat that eats only wet or only dry is getting malnourished. There are some times when she needs only dry such as the 8hrs after allergy med. My mistake with??? Cat chow. What??2 kinds of soy? So benadryl is in order but I'm not a fan of giving it to her again tonight. Wish to avoid it. People forget cats are meat eaters. She craves meat and until the finances improve the only real one is meaty bits but friskies adds soy to it. Sure they let me cut up my child's food but?? What's with the soy? Then there's liver. Mostly a no-no for cats. Why do they put that in her food too? I only buy one kind with liver and we switch off btwn 3tastes but still...if nutrient requirements bar soy and liver? Why do many brands have it? Special kitty makes her a good chicken and tuna with neither but with the rest its catch as catch can. Peppermint is working too soothe her too. ACV works for everything seriously diluted and a dab of honey and olive oil, though not together obviously. Of all the oils safe for cats olive is the best. Considering she's my first and I had no prior pet experience I think I'm doing a fine job. I just wish the perps would stop the terrorism so I could take her to a vet but that also has to wait. Unless to load their pockets they refuse help. Ya gotta remember that's an Oil. trait not an American one. Back in N J, like the rest of the country? Money isn't as important as life
 

LTS3

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2014
Messages
19,209
Purraise
19,695
Location
USA
 Diet is mostly wet. So was wondering, is friskies cheap can food the healthiest food my cats are eating?
Friskies is fine if your cats will eat it and you can afford it.  Sure there are many higher quality foods out there but if your cats won't eat it or you go broke buying it, what's the point?
. Can anyone recommend a good quality cat food that is not owned by purina or any other big companies with organ meat? I remember murr seemed good but pet store stopped carrying it.
How about Nature's Variety, specifically the grain-free Instinct line?

Murr is awfully expensive, well over $2 for a pouch of food. I doubt every many people can afford to feed that exclusively.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5

chalupa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Alpha Cat
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
322
Purraise
30
Location
Chicago
LTS3 LTS3 thanks for reply. I do pick up some cans of nature instinct at local store too, will pick up more. Lately been mostly getting Fussie cat because I have a kitten and she inhales that food! Thing is Fussie might have the boneless chicken human grade kind of meat of meat the wysong guy mentioned. The other reason Fussie was brought in was my older cat has kidney issues. Boneless chicken sounds easier for her as far as phosphorous levels. She is also why I don't give them too much dry food.
Thanks for your reply 2 2cats4me also use a little Fromm dry for my cats. Can't give one cat too much dry though,so only in moderation.
Wish the cats liked precise more, my pet store sells big cans. Still, do feed the friskies, it's pretty well received by them. Precise they don't always finish, it's ok though.
My cats also get a little organic plain kefir mixed in their food sometimes and plain goat yogurt as a treat, for probiotics, in case they need them. Figure the kitten will benefit from a little milk product.kefir is 99% lactose free.
I vary their food as much as I can. Trust no pet companies. Just hope the ones they eat are going to keep them healthy. Try to get some different meat sources in there too. Not too much fish. I'm guessing the brands that just say chicken or turkey also have organ meat. Does anyone know what just chicken might mean?
 
Last edited:

2cats4me

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 5, 2014
Messages
2,046
Purraise
211
@LTS3 thanks for reply. I do pick up some cans of nature instinct at local store too, will pick up more. Lately been mostly getting Fussie cat because I have a kitten and she inhales that food! Thing is Fussie might have the boneless chicken human grade kind of meat of meat the wysong guy mentioned. The other reason Fussie was brought in was my older cat has kidney issues. Boneless chicken sounds easier for her as far as phosphorous levels. She is also why I don't give them too much dry food.
Thanks for your reply @2Cats4Me also use a little Fromm dry for my cats. Can't give one cat too much dry though,so only in moderation.
Wish the cats liked precise more, my pet store sells big cans. Still, do feed the friskies, it's pretty well received by them. Precise they don't always finish, it's ok though.
My cats also get a little organic plain kefir mixed in their food sometimes and plain goat yogurt as a treat, for probiotics, in case they need them. Figure the kitten will benefit from a little milk product.kefir is 99% lactose free.
I vary their food as much as I can. Trust no pet companies. Just hope the ones they eat are going to keep them healthy. Try to get some different meat sources in there too. Not too much fish. I'm guessing the brands that just say chicken or turkey also have organ meat. Does anyone know what just chicken might mean?
I wish my cats liked Friskies but they don't .   If your cats like it and do well on it that is all that matters .

I did finally find a really good canned at Tractor Supply and my cats actually like it . I was shocked ..  So at least I can give them one meal of wet per day . 

I am not sure manufactures it but the ingredients are really good ..  It only comes in two flavors but my cats are not keen on rotation anyway .

http://www.tractorsupply.com/tsc/pr...key-giblet-dinner-cat-food-55-oz?cm_vc=IOPDP1
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7

chalupa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Alpha Cat
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
322
Purraise
30
Location
Chicago
Thanks @2cats4me I will look up the brand wet food. Good you give variety to your cats. Since they are fed dry maybe might help to add little water to wet food of it won't turn them off. I get paid a really low wage so I half the expensive cat health foods (I hope) with the cheap stuff. I'm the type that spends all my money on them first. They are my whole life. Just, If there is no point, if it's not healthy anyway, don't want to but the overpriced cat food of course. There is no way of knowing except, we will see how it goes.
 

siamiam2

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
434
Purraise
23
It's a lie chalupa. No extra bad stuff is in cat food. Friskies is way far better than fancy feast. I am fortunate to be able to communicate with my cat. She literally tells me good or bad, feelings etc. Nobody else is that lucky but senses are a good judge. I can tell when she just doesn't feel right. You can with yours but to be sure if you can't afford natural stuff friskies is the best and cheapest.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #9

chalupa

TCS Member
Thread starter
Alpha Cat
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
322
Purraise
30
Location
Chicago
S siamiam2 thanx so much for your help and feedback. I agree about friskies versus fancy feast because fancy feast is typically too high in phosphorous for my old cat so don't buy it. My cats seem fine on any foods luckily so far. Wish you and your cat he best.
 
Last edited:

siamiam2

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
434
Purraise
23
It's also 3ounces and unless your cat is sedentary and I do mean very sedentary, FF is bad. Your cat is old? Well then, Apple Cider vinegar is in order! At any age, but add life to her years. Get a dropper fill it a short way up, cover it with warm water and give. It really does wonders for cats. Annabel kidneys now work perfectly because of it. Last years problem looking gone.
 

tamros

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Aug 10, 2015
Messages
6
Purraise
1
My Aby is not very fond of dry food. Unfortunately I can't afford to give my cat expensive wet food and I have to go for cheaper option (mainly friskies )  but I do try to supply him with super premium dry food. After some research I bought Merrick's dry cat food for kittens but my kitty didn't like it. The food seems to be good quality, but apparently it's not enough. Then I found Solid Gold cat food and this is the only dry food he eats, not much but at least something.  

https://www.solidgoldpet.com/products/cat
 
Top