Mine liked rabbit and chicken I did not know it had carageenan so I will stick with Merrick which has carageenan, but they like better! I made mistake of picking up 10 cans of new Nutro breakfast since they like chunky chicken so much! I am returning cans today, not fans of egg and chicken! Ugh cats!!! [emoji]128576[/emoji][emoji]128576[/emoji][emoji]128576[/emoji]