How To Deal When Your Kitty's Cheating On You

omondieu

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
31
Purraise
1
Location
Toronto, ON
Hello all,

I posted a thread a few weeks ago about my cat Niko. I was concerned that he had started to take extended "vacations" from home. He's always been an outdoor cat, but would always return home to "check in" every few hours. Over the past 2 weeks, he's been disappearing for days at a time. He certainly isn't neglected or unloved, but I figured that his disappearances coincided with the increased visits from my nephew, who's very loud and high energy.

I found out where he's been sneaking off to.

He came home about three days ago, but took off again. Yesterday, a lovely old lady with Parkinson's comes to my mother's (I no longer live at home, but can't afford to have Niko with me at the moment), and says, 

"Your cat has been staying with me."

Turns out she lives a few doors down on our street. Niko's got a license, so she either phoned the vet to figure out whose cat he is, or maybe someone in the neighbourhood told her, as Niko's pretty well acquainted with the block. 

Turns out that Niko and another cat have been visiting this old lady lately. She had a cat that passed away about a year ago with whom Niko and this other cat were friendly, and would visit. She said since our cat has been coming over so much, she was concerned that his owners would be worried about his whereabouts. She says our cat and this other cat refuse to leave her alone. She's not angry about it at all as she adores cats. She says they're great company. I'm glad she appears to understand that he does have a home elsewhere, and seems content with him as a "visitor", and not a stray she can freely take in and call her own. 

I'm relieved that he's being welcomed by this lady, and isn't out frozen in the snow somewhere. I'm just curious as to whether anyone here has dealt with this kind of behaviour, or something similar. Could this be a phase? My mother's house has been something of a zoo lately, and it always gets hellish there around the holidays. I was sort of joking that Niko can probably sense the tension in the air, and needs to take a break. 

But I am actually pretty worried. He's an older cat (13 in March), and this sudden desire to go with this other cat to this old lady's house all the time has me concerned. I'm worried that he's either decided to leave us forever, or that he can feel that he's going to die soon and wants to live out the rest of his life somewhere quiet and peaceful. :( He used to visit our next door neighbours every single day, as they also have a cat Niko's friendly with, and they love him. But he doesn't even go to them, anymore. My mom says that when he does come home, he sort of seems intense, as if he's on a mission. He goes around the house, appearing to inspect every room, has a nap, grooms our other cat and plays with her, and then it's back out. What's with this urge to go down the street to stay with this woman? 
 
Last edited:

keyes

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Jan 11, 2013
Messages
445
Purraise
59
Maybe he knows that your neighbor needs a fur baby friend.
 

kittymomma1122

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Messages
577
Purraise
99
Location
Michigan
Though our life we have had two neighborhoods we lived in that had visiting cats. The first neighborhood we had a large black shorthair named Simon. He was owned by the lady next door who ran a daycare. I would come out of the kitchen and there he would be comfortably laying in my living room.  We always kept food for him because he would eat out of our dogs dish.  When we moved a neighbor two doors down had an applehead Siamese. He came in all of the neighbors houses. He liked to sleep on top of my fridge. We also had food for him because he was the boss of our dog. His name was Cocoa. When the neighbors moved they just left him behind. He lived out the remainder of his life in our house with visits to our other neighbors elderly Siamese female.  We did not have cats of our own at that time and we had a dog so no ferals in our neighborhood. I noticed that both of these cats were un-altered males. I was not in a position to alter either one as they were not my cats. When Cocoa's people moved we thought they would come back looking for him as his was a registered papered cat. They never did. He died of what we think was a heart condition while we were sleeping, we found him in the morning on our kitchen floor by his favorite window, Is your cat neutered?
 

kika the cat

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
16
Purraise
2
Location
California
Omondieu,

I had to read your story three times cause it's hard to follow.

First you talk about Niko, then you talk about "our cat", then finally you let on that you have a female cat.

How is Niko "cheating" on you if he belongs to someone else? How do you know Niko's age if he's not your cat?

Cats are territorial. Your female cat must have every edge and object tagged with her scent.

Niko knows your home belongs to another cat I'd assume. 
 
Last edited:

kittymomma1122

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Messages
577
Purraise
99
Location
Michigan
 
Cats don't like change or tension or lots of chaos... So he more than likely just found a friend who doesn't have all the chaos around them to wait it out with. 
If your kitty is neutered then I agree with P3 an The King. He is trying to find a peaceful place to be.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #8

omondieu

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
31
Purraise
1
Location
Toronto, ON
 
Omondieu,

I had to read your story three times cause it's hard to follow.

First you talk about Niko, then you talk about "our cat", then finally you let on that you have a female cat.

How is Niko "cheating" on you if he belongs to someone else? How do you know Niko's age if he's not your cat?

Cats are territorial. Your female cat must have every edge and object tagged with her scent.

Niko knows your home belongs to another cat I'd assume. 
Niko = "our cat". We also have a female cat who's a few years younger than him.  We have two cats. We know Niko's age because we got him 12 years ago when he was a kitten. He belongs to us.
 
Last edited:

kika the cat

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
16
Purraise
2
Location
California
 
Niko = "our cat". We also have a female cat who's a few years younger than him.  We have two cats. We know Niko's age because we got him 12 years ago when he was a kitten. He belongs to us.
Oh, okay. I didn't make that connection from the story. I thought Niko was an outdoor stray. Now I see your concerns.

And nice editing; the story is much clearer now.
 
Last edited:
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #10

omondieu

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
31
Purraise
1
Location
Toronto, ON
I guess the fact that Niko's coming home at all, even if it's every few days, is a good thing. I think that if he were sick or dying, he'd just go off and disappear completely. 
 

reese yu

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
Dec 14, 2014
Messages
2
Purraise
1
...... Your story had me when you typed the fact that you found him dead by his favorite window......

I'm touched and crushed.... Condolences.
 

kittymomma1122

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Messages
577
Purraise
99
Location
Michigan
I think she was looking a my post of our neighborhood Siamese that took up residence in our home after our neighbors moved and left him behind.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #14

omondieu

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
31
Purraise
1
Location
Toronto, ON
Almost a month after this whole saga began, and Niko's not even coming in the house, anymore. :( He'll come around once a week, but won't come inside when called, and moves away when we reach out to pet him. Dunno whether this is a symptom of a sickness, or whether he's just decided to leave us forever. He's always been such a friendly cat, even with strangers, so why he'd be so moody about being touched doesn't make sense to me. I'm so sad about this, and the fact that it's happening during the holidays is making it even harder. And since he's at this other lady's house all the time, we can't even take him to the vet. He used to come back home to have some food and a nap, but he's not even doing that, as this lady tells us she's feeding him. I'm hoping this is some weird phase he's going through, but I'm starting to think that I'll never see my boy, again. :( 
 

catpack

TCS Veteran
Kitten
Joined
Aug 13, 2013
Messages
3,271
Purraise
646
Location
Southeastern USA
If he is your cat, you have the right to go to the neighbor's house to collect him and get him to the vet. If you are unable to collect him yourself, it certainly seems like the neighbor would more than happily assist.

It also sounds as if Niko is taking to the neighbor's house because it is calm and quiet. Perhaps you could provide the neighbor food to feed him, especially since you are still claiming ownership? It doesn't sound as if you have any desire to keep him indoor only, which is the only way to keep him home.
 

p3 and the king

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
1,831
Purraise
127
Location
Branson, Missouri (USA)
Unfortunately outdoor cats make up their own mind... It sounds to me like he is breaking up with you.  I am sorry to say that.  But, if you want him back, you'll have to bring him in and keep him in.  Telling the lady to not feed him would be cruel and not help at all.  It's no guarantee that he would come back anyway.  He may even wander farther to find someone else who has a quieter home. 

If you do bring him in, just make a quiet area for him to escape to, if possible.  Put his toys, beds, litter box, food and water in there so he knows it's his.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #17

omondieu

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
31
Purraise
1
Location
Toronto, ON
He's long been used to sharing the space with our other cat and the rest of our family, so I find it odd that he's just decided to take up residence with this lady after she's been cat-less for a year. I feel that this change in behaviour came about when our neighbour's cat Rasha (the one he's friends with, also a neutered male) started coming over to our house recently. Rasha used to just hang around outside with Niko, but now he comes INSIDE our house, and has no qualms about eating our cats' food (he's a huge cat and eats EVERYTHING). Rasha belongs next door, to the neighbours Niko used to visit constantly, sleeping on their beds, hanging out with their kids. Now if they see him and call him, he runs away. Could he be resentful of Rasha? 
 

p3 and the king

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
1,831
Purraise
127
Location
Branson, Missouri (USA)
 
He's long been used to sharing the space with our other cat and the rest of our family, so I find it odd that he's just decided to take up residence with this lady after she's been cat-less for a year. I feel that this change in behaviour came about when our neighbour's cat Rasha (the one he's friends with, also a neutered male) started coming over to our house recently. Rasha used to just hang around outside with Niko, but now he comes INSIDE our house, and has no qualms about eating our cats' food (he's a huge cat and eats EVERYTHING). Rasha belongs next door, to the neighbours Niko used to visit constantly, sleeping on their beds, hanging out with their kids. Now if they see him and call him, he runs away. Could he be resentful of Rasha? 
It is possible.  Rasha may be an alpha and marking the territory as his.  So to avoid confrontation, Niko is finding new territory.  Again, if you want him back, he needs to be brought and kept indoors.  Either way, he will eventually stop coming altogether.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #19

omondieu

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
31
Purraise
1
Location
Toronto, ON
I had not considered that Rasha's presence in our house could be what's driving him off, but it does make sense. He's a much bigger cat than Niko, and does carry himself as an alpha kitty, and Niko has long been our alpha. He knows he can manipulate us into doing his bidding. After considering the dynamic between Niko and Rasha, I guess calling them "friends" isn't quite accurate. I'd say they're more "tolerant" of each other, but there is some tension there. They're definitely not playmates like Niko and our other cat Murka. Murka doesn't like Rasha at all - when he comes in the house, she growls and glares at him, but keeps her distance. We've also noticed that she's started biting in the past two weeks. She'll come to be petted, but as soon as someone lays a hand on her, she'll nip. Persistently, too. So Niko could be feeling displaced, and trying to assert himself elsewhere where he knows there's no competition. I think that the fact that he is still very close to home is also telling. This lady lives just a few houses down at the end of our block. My mother agreed that it seemed as though Niko's moodswings started when Rasha started visiting frequently, and says that she'll make sure Rasha isn't let inside our home anymore, and make sure that Niko understands that he's still wanted and loved. I'm also going to try to find some special treats for Niko.   

Also, I haven't been coming over as frequently for the last month and a half or so, and I'm the person with whom Niko's always been closest. I *LAVISH* him with attention. Could my absence also be contributing to his moodiness, or are cats generally not sensitive to stuff like that? Do they respond to the scents of their human friends in their homes?    
 
Last edited:

vbcatparent

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
307
Purraise
52
Location
Virginia Beach
Why did you start letting this Rasha cat come into your house when it belongs to two other cats? That's a recipe for disaster. Niko probably figures that the game in your neighborhood is for cats to audition all the houses until they find their favorite. 

If you think Niko will be happier there, and you don't want to evict Rasha, then let him become that lady's cat.

If you really want him back, you'll have to reset your house to how it was when he was happy there, then crate him and bring him inside your home for a while.
 
Top