My cats won't eat Nutro turkey soft loaf..

momof3b1g said:

 
I bought 2 cases of the turkey and 1 case of duck at Chewys. They ate the duck yesterday and today gave them the turkey. 2 wouldnt touch it.  3 ate most of it. The other 2 didnt finish it all.  Im so sick after just buying 2 cases online. they wont eat it. Its about one of the only brands they would eat before.  I want to give them some canned food every day. But its getting more expensive and harder to do when they wont eat any of it.  I have been mixing their dry with water to make sure they are getting more moisture in their diet.  I am at a loss.  Maybe its a phase because i dont think they cared much for the sheba like they did when i first bought it. 

I dont know what to do when they wont eat their afternoon meal

Click to expand...

mrsgreenjeens said:

 
Won't Chewy's take it back if your cat's don't like it?  (probably isn't worth it to pay for S & H)  Otherwise you can donate it to a shelter and take a tax write off.  The shelter cats would probably be thrilled.  OR, if they like the duck, try just mixing a little of the turkey  into the duck and see what happens...see if you can get them to eat it that way.

BTW, my cats love Nutro Turkey CHUNKY Loaf, but do NOT like the soft loaf.  It's beyond me why, but that's the way it is with them....goofballs 

Click to expand...

mrsgreenjeens said:

Won't Chewy's take it back if your cat's don't like it?  (probably isn't worth it to pay for S & H)  Otherwise you can donate it to a shelter and take a tax write off.  The shelter cats would probably be thrilled.  OR, if they like the duck, try just mixing a little of the turkey  into the duck and see what happens...see if you can get them to eat it that way.

BTW, my cats love Nutro Turkey CHUNKY Loaf, but do NOT like the soft loaf.  It's beyond me why, but that's the way it is with them....goofballs 

Click to expand...

momof3b1g said:

I bought 2 cases of the turkey and 1 case of duck at Chewys. They ate the duck yesterday and today gave them the turkey. 2 wouldnt touch it.  3 ate most of it. The other 2 didnt finish it all.  Im so sick after just buying 2 cases online. they wont eat it. Its about one of the only brands they would eat before.  I want to give them some canned food every day. But its getting more expensive and harder to do when they wont eat any of it.  I have been mixing their dry with water to make sure they are getting more moisture in their diet.  I am at a loss.  Maybe its a phase because i dont think they cared much for the sheba like they did when i first bought it. 

I dont know what to do when they wont eat their afternoon meal

Click to expand...

momof3b1g said:

I'll keep it. As some will eat it. Thats interesting about the soft loaf vs chunky. My cats had the chunky in the past. i thought they had eaten the soft loaf. i will have to remember that.
I can feed it to the others, but of course my picky cats get left out. I have been trying to feed them better quality. And grain free. Things were going good. then i bought new cases. They turned their nose up at the new case of Cowboy cookout. Merrick said they only changed the label. But the 2 picky cats wont touch it. Hopefully I can mix the duck with it. Ive got 45 cans of this and cant afford to donate it.

Click to expand...

2Cats4Me said:

Hopefully you can use it up .. I cannot buy more than a week at a time because my cats are very fickle . So far they like the FF Classic Liver & Chicken .. Today I gave them each a can of Nutro Natural Choice Chunky Turkey Loaf  and they loved it , ate the whole thing . I did have to mix in a little of their kibble which they are crazy about but I don't mind ..
[/quote

momof3b1g said:

I'll keep it. As some will eat it. Thats interesting about the soft loaf vs chunky. My cats had the chunky in the past. i thought they had eaten the soft loaf. i will have to remember that.
I can feed it to the others, but of course my picky cats get left out. I have been trying to feed them better quality. And grain free. Things were going good. then i bought new cases. They turned their nose up at the new case of Cowboy cookout. Merrick said they only changed the label. But the 2 picky cats wont touch it. Hopefully I can mix the duck with it. Ive got 45 cans of this and cant afford to donate it.

Click to expand...

If you got the duck pate, they should like it, mine do!

Click to expand...

bonepicker said:

A local pet store would probably take cans of the loaf back in exchange for the chunky loaf.

Click to expand...