Looking to try something new!

What wet food does your cat find irresistible?

Hard for me to say. Wolfie is a hound and there is no end to his appetite. He eats everything including people food. Honestly I don't think there is any food he would refuse.

zoneout said:

Hard for me to say. Wolfie is a hound and there is no end to his appetite. He eats everything including people food. Honestly I don't think there is any food he would refuse.

Click to expand...

You are very lucky! My big guy is like that! The girl is the fussy one!

My cats love Thrive Complete wet food especially the chicken variety, I order it from www.zooplus.co.uk. I find it a bit expensive now I have 2 cats so I've been trying other brands, however my older cat Eva (she's 11 now) turns her nose up at everything else lol and will just sit and look at me until I cave in and replace what I've given her. Princess my newly adopted stray isn't so fussy but she also seems to like Thrive.

I do not know if that is sold in US. I have not heard of it.

My cat is really picky but he loves two foods that are only found at Whole Foods. The Whole Paws line, and Deck Hand tuna cat food. Home runs!

I think the only brand mine finds irresistible is the Nutro Natural Choice chicken/turkey loafs.  Its the one food he licks the bowl clean.      I recently discovered that he also loves Blue Buffalo chicken and turkey in gravy.   I think he may prefer it to the Wellness pouches of the same kind. 

Performatrin Ultra Chicken Stew is always a favourite with out tortoiseshell cat Morgenne - that saucer gets licked so clean you'd never know there was cat food in it!

It's a little pricey but my family's three cats love tiki cat, I only feed the chicken varieties but they really like it.  Also anything fancy feast is a given that the cats will eat too.

SmartyFOJ said:

It's a little pricey but my family's three cats love tiki cat, I only feed the chicken varieties but they really like it.  Also anything fancy feast is a given that the cats will eat too.

Click to expand...

My boy will eat weruva chicken shreds but the girl only likes pates, so I have avoided tiki thinking it is like weruva!

Chromium Blues said:

Performatrin Ultra Chicken Stew is always a favourite with out tortoiseshell cat Morgenne - that saucer gets licked so clean you'd never know there was cat food in it!

Click to expand...

Is performatrin sold in the US?

I don't know if its sold in the US or not. I get it at Pet Valu here in Ontario. They changed the recipe in the last couple of years to a grain-free version and I was worried Morgenne wouldn't appreciate them tweaking her food, but she devours it all the same. Mind you, she's always been an easy-keeper (thank goodness!!) I will say, it does go over nicely with the majority of my cats, though.

I really like Performatrin as a brand for wet food. If you have a Pet Valu location nearby (the US locations are sparser than Canadian), check them out. It's a store brand and for the price, the quality is really good. Both Performatrin and their Ultra recipes are grain free. I consider it much better than Authority and Sheba. Another Pet Valu brand, though not nearly as high quality, is Health Diet. It's cheaper, but something about that turkey and giblets pate gets Kismet interested if she's in a bit of a rut.

My cats devoured Performatrin initially, but now it's just part of a larger rotation. They're best kept happy with constant changes and mixing recipes. If they get the same ratio of food for the same flavours even two days (sometimes two meals) in a row, they'll walk away until they get hungry enough to "resort" to the redundancy.

Wellness grain free pouches and Weruva Cats in the Kitchen pouches

My cats are like that too - gotta have the variety when it comes to canned food. Its good though, because they don't get pigeon-holed into one thing, so if one thing is sold out, there are umpteen others that will do as well.

Yeah, kind of a pain in the a--! I never thought cats would be harder than dogs to keep happy! Now I know! My dog could care less if I rotate his flavors! He is just happy to be fed![emoji]10084[/emoji]️[emoji]128062[/emoji][emoji]10084[/emoji]️[emoji]128062[/emoji][emoji]10084[/emoji]️[emoji]128062[/emoji]

That reminds me of a womyn I met in line at the grocery store awhile back. She was buying many packages of chicken breasts because that was absolutely all her little dog would eat. Unreal!

bonepicker said:

My boy will eat weruva chicken shreds but the girl only likes pates, so I have avoided tiki thinking it is like weruva!

Click to expand...

You would be right Tiki cat is shredded chicken so you should probably stay away from that brand.  I do believe Nature's Variety Instinct is more of a pate style, my cats will eat it so the chicken is in their rotation.  I tried the turkey and they don't like that flavor as much.  But I really like the ingredient list in all the instinct cans so I would recommend it. 

Chromium Blues said:

That reminds me of a womyn I met in line at the grocery store awhile back. She was buying many packages of chicken breasts because that was absolutely all her little dog would eat. Unreal!

Click to expand...

He might have been sick or on borrowed time.

SmartyFOJ said:

You would be right Tiki cat is shredded chicken so you should probably stay away from that brand.  I do believe Nature's Variety Instinct is more of a pate style, my cats will eat it so the chicken is in their rotation.  I tried the turkey and they don't like that flavor as much.  But I really like the ingredient list in all the instinct cans so I would recommend it. 

Click to expand...

Yes the rabbit in NV instinct or Pride by Instinct rockstar rabbit is both their favorites.