Buncombe tackles pet overpopulation

kiwideus

TCS Member
Thread starter
Veteran
Joined
Jul 4, 2002
Messages
13,901
Purraise
12
Location
Aotearoa
Buncombe tackles pet overpopulation
By Jennifer Brevorka, STAFF WRITER
Nov. 18, 2003 10:48 p.m.

ASHEVILLE - First Fido needed a leash. Now, he might need a snip and tuck.

Buncombe County commissioners amended animal control laws earlier this month, just weeks after a pit bull attacked a Candler boy. The new amendment requires local pet owners to physically restrain their animals anytime pets leave their property.

At a work session Tuesday, commissioners discussed another pet problem - overpopulation.

It is a dilemma that leads to the death of about 7,000 dogs and cats a year and is steadily driving up costs at the county shelter, officials said.

The solution could be imposing a fine for retrieving a pet from the shelter if that pet was not spayed or neutered. That would include owners of lost pets or those picked up by animal control officers for being a danger or nuisance to others.

"We've just hit a brick wall," said Shelly Moore, executive director of the Asheville Humane Society. "And we've got to think of a different way of dealing with this problem."

Commissioners heard suggestions Tuesday for a proposed law that would be voted on in December.

"We're seeing 10,000 animals a year come through the shelter," Moore said. "About 50 percent of those animals are strays, and the other 50 percent of those animals are turned over by owners."

"People just see these animals as disposable," she said.

Under the new regulations, pet owners, such as dog breeders, who don't want to spay or neuter their dogs or cats could buy a special permit, according to a draft of the ordinance.

"This isn't meant to be a punitive thing at all," said Ellen Frost, a former dog breeder and the owner of Bed Biscit, a dog kennel in Black Mountain.

"We need to think about people putting their liberties aside and spaying or neutering their animals to put an end to this problem. People need to realize we're slaughtering these animals."

The problem is costing taxpayers thousands of dollars a year, Frost said.

"I don't think it is fair that taxpayers have to pay the bills when they might not even have animals," Frost said.

Buncombe County will spend $665,092 for animal control and shelter costs in fiscal year 2004, county officials said. The money pays for staff, food and medical care of animals and the cost of putting animals to sleep. Asheville pays $121,000 toward shelter costs, Moore said.

"We simply cannot adopt our way out of this overpopulation problem," said Bill McKelvy, a volunteer and president of the Humane Alliance Spay/Neuter Clinic and the owner of two dogs. "And we can't build shelters large enough. (Sterilization) is an answer that solves these problems and saves taxpayers money."

At Tuesday's meeting, commissioners said they supported the proposed law but had concerns if all pet owners who wanted to spay or neuter their cat or dog could afford it.

Animal control officials said Buncombe County organizations have at least three different low-cost spay and neuter programs and more than $20,000 in grants to help.

"Anyone in this county that wants to get their pet neutered, we can help them," Moore said. "Money is not the problem though. The problem is making people want to do it."

This was in this mornings paper and on the news, I think it is a good idea to make people pay if they do not want to spay/neuter their pet.
 

lotsocats

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
May 30, 2001
Messages
5,481
Purraise
17
Location
Out Yonder in Kentucky
"Money is not the problem though. The problem is making people want to do it."
I think this sums it up. In my experience it is either laziness or just not giving a darn that keeps people from altering their pets. I hope this new idea of fining people works, but I doubt it will have much of an impact.
 

charmsdad

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Apr 27, 2003
Messages
604
Purraise
1
This is a very sad approach. Efforts to impose high taxes on un-steralized animals only impact those that would follow the law anyway, and these are usually not the people that are causing the problem. These same approaches have been tried in other areas any what happens is:

1) a lower reclaim rate (and the people will just get a new animal - with the now abandoned one ending up euthanized) and

2) a lower rate of compliance with rabies vaccination requirements - increasing the risk of rabies transmission. (Rabies vaccination is generally tied with licensing. If you raise the tax on unaltered animals then people won't get their animal vaccinated so they won't get the tax notice.)

As for spay/neuter, a study done in upstate New York found that cost was not the primary issue in getting people to spay/neuter their animals. The most important issues were:

1) Gender: males were far less likely to spay/neuter their animal

2) education level of the owners (lower education levels tied directly with lower rates of spay/neuter)

3) Initial cost of animal: the lower the initial cost the less likely the animal would be spay/neutered

There was much more from the study, but not room here.

George
 

hissy

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 19, 2001
Messages
34,872
Purraise
78
We really need the cooperation of veterinarians nationwide to provide say one week every month where they will spay or neuter for such a low price that anyone can afford to get this procedure done on their cats. There are only a smattering of professionals that do this now- but just think if every single vet in every clinic across the United States did this, the problem wouldn't be quite so overwhelming. But in a perfect world, I guess. And this world is far from perfect when it comes to the complete care of animals.
 

tnr1

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 5, 2003
Messages
7,980
Purraise
13
Location
Northern Virginia
Utah did this and it was really successful. They offered low cost spays and neuters for people (it was really targeted at men) and then the person and their pet got to take a picture with the hooter girls.

Katie
 

lotsocats

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
May 30, 2001
Messages
5,481
Purraise
17
Location
Out Yonder in Kentucky
Originally posted by TNR1
Utah did this and it was really successful. They offered low cost spays and neuters for people (it was really targeted at men) and then the person and their pet got to take a picture with the hooter girls.
I love it! What a great way to get people to neuter their pets!
 
Top