Need opinions on PJ's diet

prairiepanda

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 6, 2013
Messages
264
Purraise
141
Location
Canada
PJ has been playing games with me over her food choices, being a real princess like her name implies(PJ = Princess Jasmine) If you've got any advice or input that might help improve the situation a bit I'd be grateful. Let me explain how I've been managing PJ's diet for the last couple months:

PJ gets 3/8 cup of kibble every morning, which she snacks on throughout the day. I put out a different flavor or brand of kibble every day. If she gets the same flavor every day, she will grow tired of it within a week and start losing weight because she'll eat very little of it. Right now there are 3 brands in rotation: Orijen, California Natural, and Merrick's Purrfect Bistro. She is starting to get tired of the Orijen and Merrick's, but still loves the California Natural. I might try getting different flavors of Orijen and Merrick's, or a new brand like Spot's Stew Grain-Free. PJ's poop has been normal, so I think she's okay with having different kibble each day as long as the formulas aren't too extremely different, but it's frustrating having to buy so much food all the time just because she's bored of the taste...is there a better way to go about this?

PJ's evening meal is a 1/4 cup of a home-made mix, and I alternate this between 2 slightly different flavors. She is starting to get bored of one flavor. My recipe consists of cooked ground turkey(all fluids conserved), TC Feline premix, egg yolks(cooked with the turkey), krill oil, glucosamine, chondroitin, (vitamins dosed according to vet recommendations, based on a usual recipe output of 25 servings/25 days), and a can or two of smelly cat food for flavor. The recipe itself seems to be doing good things for PJ, and I can make different flavors by using differing kinds of canned cat food, but I don't want to be filling my freezer with several batches of cat food.

The dietitian at PJ's vet clinic has approved of this plan, as well as my home-made recipe, only cautioning that I not choose any drastically different kibble formulas for PJ's breakfast. So far PJ's health and mobility has been fantastic, and the only time she ever vomits is when she eats plastic bags(I haven't quite trained my roommate not to leave them out where PJ can get at them). But PJ's tendency to get bored of her food is a bit of a problem. When she gets bored of a flavor, she'll start eating less and less of it until she won't touch it at all. At that point, I have to stop offering it for a few weeks before she'll touch it again, and she still won't show the same enthusiasm as when it was brand new. I'm concerned that I'll be accumulating cat food that will go uneaten for long periods of time and possibly expire before I can get my money's worth. I have tried sprinkling crushed treats and other flavor enhancers over food that PJ is losing interest in, but that only works for a couple days.

Does anyone else have cats who do this? Any advice that might help me get PJ to eat consistently?
 

vball91

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
3,851
Purraise
250
Location
CO, USA
Does PJ ever get tired of the homemade mix? How about trying to feed that twice a day instead of the kibble? Maybe she doesn't like kibble, which wouldn't be a bad thing. :)
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #3

prairiepanda

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 6, 2013
Messages
264
Purraise
141
Location
Canada
I currently have 2 different flavors of the homemade food which I alternate every day just like the kibble, as she does grow tired of it(she's starting to get bored of one flavor right now)...it does take her much longer to get bored of the homemade food than kibble, though. Right now it would cost me too much to give her only homemade food, but in the future I'll be able to transition her away from kibble altogether. Although, if anyone has any tips to reduce the cost of my homemade cat food I might be able to make it work. (I won't remove the added vitamins, though, as I have noticed a great increase in playfulness and flexibility after I started including them)

But either way I'd like to find an easier way to deal with PJ's food boredom than hoarding several flavors of food. I've tried to make "boring" food more appetizing by adding or reducing moisture and temperature, but PJ doesn't seem to care. She demands new flavors! It's frustrating when I try to reintroduce an old flavor that she hasn't eaten in weeks only to find that she still doesn't like it, so there's a half-full bag of kibble(or several containers of homemade food) sitting around that might not ever get eaten. It's particularly frustrating with the kibble, because there's a limited selection of decent quality kibble in my town.
 
Top