Sugar and Spice love squeaky mice and the little furry mice that come a dozen in a package. Julie likes water jug rings. Sheba loves crumpled paper. Silly will sometimes play with all of these.
Sugar also likes empty 20oz bottles (with cap on) and empty aluminum cans.
My cats love Neko flies. The Kragonfly one is their favorite. They also love Kong Kickeroo's, the frog one is the favorite for some reason . One time my cat was laying in bed and he got out to get the frog kickeroo then hopped back in bed with it. So cute!They also love these little spring toys that look like slinkies. They roll them across the floor and chase them. Hartz catnip mice are popular around here too.