What should I do?

mai_kitties

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
255
Purraise
17
Location
Ohio
It's been quite awhile since I posted on this site, but I am in need of some advice regarding a possible stray who may not be a stray... but well here is the backstory. Sorry it's going to be long.

About a year after we moved into our house, an adorable orange cat started coming around. Very friendly and wore a little bell around his neck. He would come to our yard and hang out but would always go home. We saw him one day on a walk and figured out he lived two doors down. We assumed this cat was new to the family since we never saw him before. We really didn't know these neighbors at all either, just would nod hi when we would walk by. Fast forward a few month's later and the house got foreclosed on. We saw the kitty a few times and then one day we noticed the house had been boarded up. We stopped seeing him around that time. Worried that he might have been in the house we poked around and talked to neighbors. Kitty was not in the house.

We then found out after talking to neighbors that this kitty had belonged to the old lady who lived there. Her son and family had moved in when the lady started getting really sick and that was about the time we started seeing this kitty outside (had never seen him before). The lady died and the family just stayed as long as they could before they were kicked out. It was assumed that the family must have taken the kitty with them. 

Flash forward several months to late October. Kitty shows up in our back yard cold and hungry. We feed him and love on him, but don't bring him in. We talk to one of our neighbors and she said this was the first she has seen him too. Several weeks of him just coming by and hanging out and us feeding him and then he disappears again. It was also around about that time that we were starting to think of bringing him in, but then he was gone. We worried a bit and checked local shelters and asked neighbors but no one had seen him.

Almost one year later, late October or early November, kitty shows back up. Great condition but starving and cold. We now know that he has a family. We assume that he must have gotten out, but the coincidence of him showing back up at the same exact time is a little unsettling. Several weeks go by and it's getting cold again and we make the decision that we are going to bring him in. The next night we are waiting for him and he never comes home. We started to fear the worst when we heard that there was some aggressive dog at our neighbors house across the street and the police came and there was talk that this dog had gotten a cat. My husband wandered the neighborhood, we stopped at the shelter, I found the police report for the dog incident but there was no mention of a cat in it. We asked around, nothing. I felt so guilty that this cat may be dead. I told my husband that if we saw him again he was coming in and we would find the owners.

Now on to this year... Late October comes and goes and I can't help but think that he was gone. And then tonight... almost one month to the day that we saw him the first time late October... guess who is in our back yard. I almost cried, I knew it was him immediately. When we pulled in the drive way he was just sitting there like he was waiting for us. He was so very scared and hungry. This cat is so friendly that he let me, practically a stranger, pick him up and take him into the house. He is now sleeping comfortably in a cat bed.

So now onto the what should I do part.

First every year since this poor cat lost his owner at almost the same exact time each year, he shows up at our house hungry and scared. We first thought he must have escaped but then the second year it was a little suspect and this year I have no doubt something is not right with this scenario. Of course our first thought is someone is going on vacation and kitty gets the boot out of the house so he goes back to the place he knows.

Second... he is not neutered, yet this is obviously an inside house cat and by all appearances well cared for.[font=arial, helvetica, clean, sans-serif]  Ears are clean, fur is well kept, eyes and nose are clear. There is no wear on the nails but they desperately need [/font][font=arial, helvetica, clean, sans-serif]cut and the paw pads are clean.[/font]

If this were an outside cat from the area, then we would see him all the time. We know all the strays in the area and he only shows up for a few weeks around this time of year.

We want to find the owners, but I really don't know what to say to these people if they do come forward. I mean honestly I don't want this cat leaving my house un-neutered regardless and plan to make an appointment for him Monday morning. That is non-negotiable to me. 

So what should I do. I don't think I can think logically in this case and could be jumping to conclusions, but really this whole situation seems fishy to me.
 

StefanZ

Advisor
Staff Member
Advisor
Joined
Sep 18, 2005
Messages
26,043
Purraise
10,734
Location
Sweden
Fishy yes. 

I think you CAN if you wish, play stupid and just adopt him, as keeping him is possible for you and entirely acceptable for you. Neuter and have him as you inside cat.

It is surely a very good solution for the cat.

Or if you want to be scrupulously honest, take him in and help him. Simultaneously seek after owners yes.  Put up messages "Found" at message boards in the vicintity. Shelters nearby, vets nearby.

Dont describe him too exactly. Let the owners identify themselves by exact description. - You dont want peculiar people get a cat for free, perhaps as sparring to their fighter dogs.

Dont give your real telephone, use a prepaid card to a cell/mobile phone.

And or an non descriptive mail at yahoo.

And if / when they phone, do talk with them, and listen what they say and how they say it.  if there is a good and natural explanation - tell your concerns, and make them promise they wont let him out again, and also, they neuter him.  (he was perhaps running after a females? They toms get sometimes as most touchy in september, even worse than in mars...  Our oldest resident, a stud, got always crises in september)

If you you get bad vibs - you end the talk with telling a white lie "it doesnt seems to be the same cat, good luck with your searching" and keep him...

Tx for caring!

Good luck!
 
Last edited:

otto

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 7, 2008
Messages
9,837
Purraise
197
Adopt him. Neuter him and have him chipped. Keep him in. He has Chosen you. Congratulations on being Chosen, it is a great honor!

Save all bills you've paid in his vet care.
 
Last edited:
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4

mai_kitties

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
255
Purraise
17
Location
Ohio
Thanks to both of you on the advice. We do think we are going to put out some notices with "found cat, you must describe" and see what turns up. He is absolutely getting neutered no matter what 
. He also definitely has some fleas. Put some Frontline Plus on him last night and found a dead one on him this morning.

As for keeping him, we are undecided right now. We currently have nine cats that we have rescued from various perilous positions and financially can care for another, but we tend to keep the ones that are unadoptable. We are prepared to keep him but will probably see if a friend or family member would adopt him first. That is unless my husband becomes attached 
. He is already talking baby talk to him. 

I do have to say that I am beyond happy that he came back to us. We used to have a lot of outdoor cats around the area, mostly semi-ferals who were cared for by a lady on another street, but we have noticed that they are dwindling in number so we are not sure what is going on. 
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5

mai_kitties

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
255
Purraise
17
Location
Ohio
Not a peep so far from his owner. I've had several calls from people who are searching for their cats and I feel so bad every time I have to tell them that this is not their cat :(

I keep thinking that I should give his owner the benefit of the doubt. Maybe the cat sitter accidentally let him out (you know every year for the past 3 years now) or he just get's his boy urges at this time of year (again hard to feel sorry for the owner... I don't know, maybe neuter your cat), but in either case there should be flyers or an ad or something after this many days. 
 

ritz

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Apr 2, 2010
Messages
4,656
Purraise
282
Location
Annapolis, MD
I agree with Otto.  Get the cat neutered, Adopt him.  He has chosen you.

And if the pet sitter had accidentally let him out, the owners would by now be putting up "LOST CAT" notices and combing the area.

And the fact that he is not neutered is telling (unless he is breed quality).  (As I understand it, boys get their urges 24x7x365 unless neutered.)
 
Top