Inferior and Superior

coalsmommy

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
38
Purraise
10
Location
Gretna, La. USA
Okay, so this kind of has something to do with cats. You see, a friend of my boyfriends... we will call her Natasha... she has the sister of my Coal. We decided to have a kitty play date tonight!

We were all super excited to see if they would remember each other, and reunite with ease, due to the hard start they had in life.

When Asher (the kitty) and Natasha arrived, Coal, my kitty, was not pleased at all. Normally, he is very loving! He is an active kitty, and can play in an aggressive manner, but in general, he is a fun loving sweet cat.

Coal was hissing at Asher and Natasha. Natasha is the self-proclaimed kitty expert. She kept trying to approach him. I tried telling her that by approaching him in his domain makes him feel threatened. If she would just leave him be, he may eventually come to her. I expressed the need to remember that we had brought another cat into his domain!!!

Nathasha didn't listen, and continued to approach him periodically. I picked Coal up and held him while she talked to him. Coal kept hissing at her, and I said maybe it's best to just let him go. She didn't listen, and she took a step closer and tried to touch him. Coal lashed and scratched her nose. You could see that one of his claws punctured her skin on her nose. We immediately put peroxide on the end of some q-tips and applied it to the puncture.

Asher stayed in the kitchen with us all night. Thus, Coal roamed else where. Anytime Coal would come into the kitchen, Natasha would tell Asher, "You can totally take him. You're twice his size! Stand your ground, let him know who is boss!" She kept making comments about how her cat could kick my cats ass. She said that Asher was stronger, faster, and sleeker. What she fails to realize is, Coal is a climber and her can run like the wind. She has never seen him run, so to say that her cat is faster is just arrogant. What she also doesn't realize is that the only advantage her cat has over mine is weight.

I tried showing her pictures of how to tell the different weight classifications, and her cat is morbidly obese! All she feeds her cat is dry food. She is, also, still giving her cat formula twice a day. We have tried to convince her that dry food should not be her main courses in her diet, but rather snacks to help keep her full. Wet food is better for a cat. She knows it all, though.

Another thing she failed to realize was that Coal was acting like a cat naturally acts. He was protecting his domain and letting them know we are his humans and this is his house! He is the man here! Asher, reacted the way she would in nature, as well. This is, indeed, your domain, and I respect that. I don't want to fight, this is your kingdom. You are the man... here.

What I don't understand, is the constant comparison. Why does she feel the need to say her cat is faster, and stronger and blah blah blah.... and most importantly, why would she keep making the comment her cat can totally kick my cats ass? Are we cat fighters now? Should we keep letting them antagonize each other to the point of them fighting? Is that really a normal mentality for someone to have?

She was really upsetting me. I started comparing them in my own head after a while... which I'm sure you've gathered in this post. I would love some insight on how to handle situations like this... because I was ready to explode! I was ready to bring up all sorts of web sites showing her how UNHEALTHY her cat really is. She mentioned that Asher isn't very playful, that she just chills a lot. I wanted to just not bite my tongue and say, "That's because she doesn't have the energy to play because she's morbidly obese." But of course, I bit my tongue.
 

carolina

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
14,759
Purraise
215
Location
Corinth, TX
Hum...... Well.... Cats are not dogs and play dates like this don't work. For cats to get along it usually takes a longer, formal introduction - yep, even if they are blood related, but have been separated. They are very territorial, and the bottom line is, her cat just invaded your cat's territory.
As far as comparison goes, IMHO, I just read the same thing in your post.... (sorry
I know how hard it is when someone talks about our babies).
I would just drop it.... You love your kitty
just like she loves hers
. None is better than the other, they are just different - it just so happens, yours is, well, yours
.
You can try to educate her on nutrition and stuff, but not as to compare - for the good of the kitty. Know though, that cats CAN be healthy on dry food only - sure, not the best, but things vary from cats to cats.... I for one, have one cat that won't eat wet food even if it is the last thing in the universe
Also, some foods that you's think are bad because of the ingredients, just might work for some kitties - Cats are complex creatures that way.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #3

coalsmommy

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
38
Purraise
10
Location
Gretna, La. USA
I definitely started comparing kitties. I got on the defense and was comparing them in my head... and in my post, obviously. I think I mentioned that, but if not, I totally intended to. I know it's not right, and I'm just flabbergasted. I wasn't expecting such behavior from a thirty year old woman; especially not one who we consider a friend. Her behavior caught me off guard, and was definitely not appreciated.

It really upset me that my boyfriend went along with her, as well. He made me feel like he feels we are doing a bad job with our kitty.

Also, we learned the hard way that no foreign animals will be welcomed as friends of Coal. No more play dates... with any animal!! Sibling or not.
 

Winchester

In the kitchen with my cookies
Veteran
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
29,756
Purraise
28,131
Location
In the kitchen
I would never allow anybody, friend or not, to bring another animal into my cats' house. It's just not going to happen. The introduction period isn't going to occur within a few minutes or even the few hours or so that friends would normally visit. It's simply too short of a period and your Coal is going to act exactly the way he did....it's normal.

Cats are very territorial animals and it's not easy to bring another animal into their domain. And I think, too, that even with siblings, once they've been apart for awhile, they wouldn't treat each other like siblings; they're strange cats and would be treated as such by each other.

I could be wrong, but I just don't think it's a good idea. (And it would save you the stress, too
)
 

ldg

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jun 25, 2002
Messages
41,310
Purraise
842
Location
Fighting for ferals in NW NJ!
Well, you learned the hard way - cats are territorial, blood relatives or no. And who wants their kitty to beat up another one? Or be able to? Who cares? I really don't get it.
Thankfully Asher deferred to your kitty in his territory. At least Asher's polite even if her mom isn't.


I'm so sorry your BF thinks a morbidly obese cat is healthier. The bottom line is, you know better. Either your BF is willing to learn... or he's someone willing to base opinions on lack of knowledge.

Personally, I think I'd be more worried about BF's response than anything else. As you know there's no point in the "my kitty is better than you kitty" game.
 

resqchick

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
1,080
Purraise
14
Location
Chasing Da Bird...
I think you got great responses, I just wanted to comment on how rude that was. if someone came to my home with their child (for example) then encouraged her child to beat up my child, she'd be leaving with half the hair on her head, and probably a set of handcuffs for encouraging bullying and abuse.

Unfortunately, you can only teach those who are willing to learn, and it seems she is not. tell her how wonderful her cat is (of course he is, he has the same genetics as Coal, right?) and let it be.
 

cheylink

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Aug 31, 2005
Messages
8,259
Purraise
102
Location
queens, new york
Originally Posted by resqchick

I think you got great responses, I just wanted to comment on how rude that was. if someone came to my home with their child (for example) then encouraged her child to beat up my child, she'd be leaving with half the hair on her head, and probably a set of handcuffs for encouraging bullying and abuse.

Unfortunately, you can only teach those who are willing to learn, and it seems she is not. tell her how wonderful her cat is (of course he is, he has the same genetics as Coal, right?) and let it be.
Well said
! How dare she try to force her uneducated opinion on you and your kitty, and her kitty! Her boyfriend said what and who is he again?
Don't for a second question anything other then your previous taste in friends
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #8

coalsmommy

TCS Member
Thread starter
Young Cat
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
38
Purraise
10
Location
Gretna, La. USA
Originally Posted by resqchick

I think you got great responses, I just wanted to comment on how rude that was. if someone came to my home with their child (for example) then encouraged her child to beat up my child, she'd be leaving with half the hair on her head, and probably a set of handcuffs for encouraging bullying and abuse.

Unfortunately, you can only teach those who are willing to learn, and it seems she is not. tell her how wonderful her cat is (of course he is, he has the same genetics as Coal, right?) and let it be.
I think you've hit the nail on the head here. This is exactly what I was trying to express to my boyfriend!
I just felt like he didn't care. We talked about everything the next day, and turns out he completely agrees. He believes that they are both awesome little kitties in their own little ways, but Asher definitely isn't as healthy or happy of a kitty as our Coal. He said to me, and I quote, "I'm glad we got the kitten we got, and we've raised him to the best of our ability... and every time I see Natasha and her cat... I know we're doing a great job!"

As for the telling her how wonderful her cat is... I now think that's what my boyfriend was doing.... being polite. It's like a parent with their children... we raise our kitten our way, she raises her kitten her way. Nobody is right or wrong, and how dare someone try and tell you that you are raising them and parenting the wrong way! Mind your own business and raise your own kitty... and that's what we shall do.


I was still very upset and flabbergasted at the time of the original post.
 
Top