Is one cat enough?

2 is always better than one in my opinion! Get him a friend. Not only will he have a baby, but you'll be giving another baby a great home.

Depends on the cat.

If the cat gets along with others, as it sounds like this one was since he was already kitty socialized, then the advantage is companionship when you are out and they can keep each other more active and thus healthy. Also usually means less harassment at night or when you're busy, since they can give up and just play w/ each other provided they have food, and its super cute when they are snuggling together or grooming each other and play wrestling. Two cats also means that even when one isn't in the mood for schmoozeling, the other likely is when you're receptive. And of course you are saving another kitty.

Some downsides are that introducing a new cat requires effort, and there is the risk of the new cat not being socialized towards other cats, or if they are far apart in age difference then say a kitten annoying your existing cat with a mismatched energy level. Two kitties can share most things, but do use more litter, more food, and more vet costs. Not as easy to monitor exact food/water intake or know whose stools are whose for managing health, but not a serious challenge. Worst case scenario with a bad match, the kitties can just end up stressing each other out rather than being friends.

Overall though, I'm definitely a strong proponent of two kitty households, and your cat is already used to other kitties when younger, so I give it the thumbs up!

Best of luck!

What age and gender kitty were you looking at as a homeslice for Jake?

I think 2 cats is the answer! A way to bring it up to hubby is that the 2 kitties will play together during the day, and then Jake (and other kitty) will sleep better at night.... He will probably want to sleep next to his buddy, and won't try to sleep on hubby's pillow!!!!

I hear you! I almost can't live with myself for the looks that Holland gives me when I am getting ready for work... She is a scaredy-cat too, and I am the only human she will let near her, but she was living in a room full of cats when I adopted her from the shelter, so I know she's had past experience with other kitties. As soon as my living and financial situations allow it, she will have a brother or sister, whether she likes it or not! (Though I'm sure she will love the company when I'm at work all day).

Good luck!

ETA: I would love to see pictures of Jake. Your descriptions of him are fabulous!

Some kitties are loners but your kitty sounds social so I bet he'd just love it if he had a sibling

1 is never enough! I never could make my mother understand that, which is why Lynxx wound up a loner for 9 years.

Since your cat has been with other cats, and doesn't fight with them. That might be a good sign that he'd be open to the idea of having a friend or 2

Based on how things went for me, I'd suggest getting a cat around the same age as your cat. Or 2 kittens.

The pros of having more than 1: More furry friends to play with and love. More furry friends to love you. They occupy each other so you don't have to constantly keep them occupied. They are company for each other when they are home alone.

The cons of having more than 1: You need to have money for the vet, especially if things happen to 2 or more cats at the exact same time. (that happened to us. Lynxx sick and dying. Midnight getting a cold, Luna getting Luxating Patella. There were times back in November that we were up at the vets 2-3 times a day, with 3 different cats!) (Also problems back to back with different cats. Lynxx died, a week later Midnight caught a cold, and had Struvite Crystals, a couple of weeks after that Luna's legs were bothering her even more, then Midnight hurt his paw, and had to have surgery) so you really need to have back up money incase of an emergency. Food is a problem with mine someone literally has to stand over Midnight and watch him while they eat, otherwise he'll push Luna out of the way eat her food on her, she won't fight back, she'll just sit there and let him. Also if 1 cat needs a certain food, and the others don't. Plus if 1 get's sick the others can catch it. We luck out with Luna and Midnight, they play very rough, but they don't really fight each other. They will fight each when I'm making their food, or if 1 is laying where the other 1 wants to lay, they'll fight then.

If you think he'd do well w/ another cat, since he's lived with them in the past, I think he would do fine. Some cats need to be only kitties, as they do not like others.

I wouldn't worry too much about sex - male or female really truly doesn't matter. I know some people think it does, but you never know - if you're dead set on a certain sex you may look past your purrfect match. I definitely suggest going about the same age, try to match energy levels/purrsonalities as best you can.