Dry Food at Petco

Which of these brands would be the better choice (I'm looking for the healthiest ingredients. Currently, my cats are getting California Natural, but I'm almost out of the bags I stocked up with before they were sold to P&G. I don't trust P&G, so I guess I have to look for something else. Basically, I was something with chicken main ingredient and not a lot of unnecessary stuff. They do get wet food, this is just to supplement at night, but I want the best quality food I can get them to eat.

These are the brands I think I can get at Petco.

Castor & Pollux
Spa Select
Blue Buffalo
Wellness

I don't know if they'll eat Wellness, I tried it before and they wouldn't. Also tried Spa Select at one point.

If there is a better kind I can get any of them online, so please do recommend.

Of those Blues wilderness ... The rest are IMHO high grain ... The healthiest ingrediants is going to vary person to person and cat to cat ....

If you are looking at something that is closer to what they have eaten look at Natural choice and Natural balance ( ingrediant wise these are closer than the ones you gave us)

Originally Posted by sharky

Of those Blues wilderness ... The rest are IMHO high grain ... The healthiest ingrediants is going to vary person to person and cat to cat ....

If you are looking at something that is closer to what they have eaten look at Natural choice and Natural balance ( ingrediant wise these are closer than the ones you gave us)

Click to expand...

I don't want to give them Natural Choice, but I will try Natural Balance. I can get that closer to home anyway. That's what I've been trying to find, something close to what they have been getting. I'm so mad that I have to think about switching them.

I've fed Blue for a while now...before just the regular variety, and then their new Longevity stuff, and most recently (i.e., the last few months) they've had to be on Basics due to allergies. I like the food, it seems to work well for the kitties, and their health is good, their shedding seems less than before, and their boxes are less full of awfulness when cleaned. I'm pretty happy with the food and would definitely recommend it.