TheCatSite.com › Forums › Our Feline Companions › Behavior › Cat Shock Collars
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Cat Shock Collars

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
I was looking to buy a cat shock collar when Google directed me to this web site. I read a few of the negative and ill in-formed opinions expressed, and felt compelled to give my "two cents" worth. Thus, I have signed up and now can not find the forum that I originally saw. Sorry.

I have a rescued cat from the local shelter. We have had her for five years now. Prior to her arrival, we have two small dogs. They use a doggie door to go in and out at their leisure. Our kitty soon learned by watching and natural curiosity that she too, could get out. Fearing for her safety (getting lost, cars, coyotes) we purchased a cat shock collar.

We tried it on ourselves, by carrying the collar towards the doggie door where we set up the receiver. It feels like any "shock" you would get from something mild....the usual tingling in the fingers. Even one of the 4 year old grandchildren picked it up. They just dropped it and started laughing because it felt "weird".

If our kitty gets to close to the door, she gets a warning beep. She turns away. She knows exactly how close she can get and sit. If the battery goes dead, and we don't catch it, she knows that too and will be out the doggie door.

During the winter, she does not wear it at all. I guess the cold and the snow hinders her enthusiasm to go outside. During the summer when I go into the fenced in back yard, I take it off of her and she stays in the back yard. When I go in, I call her from whatever bush she is under and her and the dogs trot right in.

We have recently acquired another kitty from the shelter. He has not figured out why or how the dogs go outside. But come Spring and him getting older, I know he will figure it out. And yes, for his safety, I will put one on him.

Because of my experience with the collar over the past 5 years, I can truthfully say that there is no cruelty involved. My cat is beautiful, loving, playful, spoiled with toys, has a six foot cat condo, and free access to a two storey home......except the five feet around the doggie door.
post #2 of 7
I don't think they're necessarily cruel. I just think that they probably would not be effective in keeping a cat in a yard. To keep a cat away from one point (the dog door), for most cats will likely be effective. But as a perimeter fence, no; I think most cats will run right through if given enough incentive.
post #3 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by Willowy View Post
But as a perimeter fence, no; I think most cats will run right through if given enough incentive.
Or if scared and running from something else. A truly frightened cat won't feel it.

I assume the backyard is fenced for the dogs? Depending on the existing fence height (won't work with anything under 6ft) it's not that hard to convert a fenced backyard to a cat proofed fenced backyard. Then everyone can go out and play together.
post #4 of 7
My friend bought a dog one and it was very powerful and her dog cried every time she used it, so she binned it ! x
post #5 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruthyb View Post
My friend bought a dog one and it was very powerful and her dog cried every time she used it, so she binned it ! x
They vary so much in strength. I remember one of my friend's dogs, who would sometimes go hunting with us, was put on a Mexican shock collar, and it burned two 1/4" holes into his flesh. It was really bad, and it also got chucked after that. The ironic and infuriating part was that his parents got the Mexican one because it was stronger than U.S. laws allow.

To the OP, I do agree that you are using that collar in the best way possible. It would be entirely different if it were around the perimeter of the yard, but it's a good deterrent for one indoor chokepoint location.
post #6 of 7
I believe this is the thread you wanted:
http://www.thecatsite.com/forums/sho...ighlight=fence

The door implementation would be far more foolproof than the other OP's.

Appreciate the input, but you aren't likely to change any minds. Most don't have personal experience with it to sway their opinions, they just don't like it on principle for their or any other animal. Thats why it isn't really a debate about WHICH brand or implementation specifically, but whether or not its ok to use electric shock to deter an animal, period. Same kind of situation with the new laser declaw debate, as its more a fundamental issue of whether or not anyone has a RIGHT to remove a cat's claws, even if new technologies minimize risk, pain, and recovery... its not really about that.
post #7 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by strange_wings View Post
I assume the backyard is fenced for the dogs? Depending on the existing fence height (won't work with anything under 6ft) it's not that hard to convert a fenced backyard to a cat proofed fenced backyard. Then everyone can go out and play together.
The ones I had seen were very expensive, which involved either flattening the inside surface to prevent climbing, or installing a hinged net on the top.

But you still have the issue of the cat being VERY limber, intelligent, and being able to fit through small openings.

My neighbors had to put the shock collar back on for example as her tiny dogs kept ending up in my backyard. For the life of us, we couldn't believe how flat they were able to make their bodies to squeeze through a tiny indentation they dug on the fenceline. Really nice super friendly dogs, but scared my kitties and I was getting tired of picking up dog poop.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Behavior
TheCatSite.com › Forums › Our Feline Companions › Behavior › Cat Shock Collars