Hey Sylorna - wet food, wet food, wet food.

You've asked, and you've received some great suggestions.

The eating issues my cats have all lead back to me.

I'm being educated about cat's diets - but, when the rubber meets the road, and I have cats climbing my leg, yelling, etc., it's a difficult thing to be strong.
Someone gave the advice - can't remember who, or where - that when the cat(s) start demanding food or else!!, it's best just to leave the house.

We, too, have several cats with different diet needs - it's tough to comply.
We have one that is overweight - he's the Man of his family, and everyone else moves out of the way when he's already eaten through his food, and begins working on theirs.
(The Gray Family is of whom I speak.) The Man is the daddy, and very macho, - naturally a big cat so his family lets him do whatever he wants.

But, I was surprised yesterday ... Gray had eaten through his food, and began to eat on his son's - that's when I stepped in, and showed him to back off (I found the Signal after watching my other cats put up their paw to stop the intruder) ... I put up my hand (paw) to stop his vision of the son's plate, and said "NO".
Gray backed off - so, maybe he does know he shouldn't be taking the other cat's food, hmmmm?
Just sayin' - I know it's hard - but I hope you are able to find what will work for you and your cats.

There are some DVM's that will tell you any wet food is better than kibble - but, I guess it all depends on who you talk to about diet.
Vets - like human Medical Drs., don't seem to be trained in diet issues - they rely on the salesman's word, and then parrot the salesperson's words to the patient.
Right now, I like what Lisa A. Pierson, DVM has to say about cat food:
http://www.catinfo.org/
in case you'd like to browse her information.
The owner of the pet store that I frequent will order food for me - our FeLV cat I have on wet food only, no grain - and right now he's on Merrick's Cowboy Cookout, and Wellness Turkey (no grain). He's cooped up in a bedroom with little activity - his weight is perfect.
Sounds like the portions you're feeding is a starvation diet, to me ??? but then, what do I know!

I hope the 1/6 of a can is at least a 5.5 oz can. How can you divide that up into such small portions? WOW!

We have three on Royal Canin Urinary SO - canned. They only get the dry as a treat when I go to bed, and then it's less than 1/8th of a cup each. The canned food is the primary diet, and they get from 3/4 of a can (6.5oz) to 1 can each per day --- and, they are not over weight.
The Gray family (4 of them) is another whole story - Gray was a stray that brought along his feral "wife", having 2 feral kittens before I had all altered.
They've been outside, and free feeding (dry) with both the canned food (Trader Joes Turkey - 59¢ per 5.5 oz can - in the A.M., then 1-2 can(s) in the P.M. (no doubt they had help while they were outside).
We just brought them all inside, and they are no longer free feeding the dry. I put down 1 can of food in the A.M., maybe a little more for "lunch", and in the P.M. Before bed they get treats of dry Royal Canin Urinary SO. Every other day I fix some chicken tenders and broth for them (yummy).
I don't cook for myself, but those eyes!! those eyes!!! - they love the chicken broth.
Gray is my FIV - and if I can't get his weight down, other health issues will come.
I write all this just to say - we all have issues with feeding adventures - and TCS members give good suggestions, we just have to figure out what works for us and the cats we care about - and then, be strong. (ha!

)
For me - the food may cost a little more, but if what I am feeding causes health problems - the vet bill will cost more - not to even mention the suffering that the cat goes through without a nutritional diet.
I don't like the Prescription diet either, but until I find what else works, I'm stuck. We just had a $1500 surgery for bladder stones because our Phoebe loved the dry Natural Balance so much - and I couldn't refuse her eyes, and her fancy pants dance - well, she paid for my weakness, as we paid the bill.
Dry is nasty stuff

- at least for our Furfamily - and now it's only used as treats.
I hope you find something, that works for both you and your cats.
