Nuts(inside male) is the largest at a 12 lbs and some change, Half-Tail(outside female) is less than 5 lbs and they are all from the same litter. Attitude(inside female), Runt and Goldie Jr(both outside males) are all on the big side, Attitude was around 9.5 lbs at her last vet appointment but she has gained weight back so she is at least 10 lbs. Not sure how big Goldie Jr and Runt are(and neither one would let me weigh them even if I wanted to) but I'd say 8 -10 lbs each.
Runt was actually the runt of the litter(duh, how do you think he got his name) but Half-tail I guess being female grew a lot slower. Attitude and Nuts have a small size difference Nuts is longer and taller than Attitude.
The moms are small though, Mama who is grandma is around 5-6 lbs(don't know exactly and don't feel like being ripped up trying to find out) Biter and Goldie(who disappeared never to be seen again, I think she became coyote chow) were also on the small side. Biter is bigger than Mama but is less than 7-8 lbs. Goldie was also about the same size as Biter.
Understand their dad was a HUGE black and white extremely short haired cat, he was almost like a Spinx but with really short hair, I've never seen a cat with hair that short(Attitude has the same marking but much much longer hair), standing on all 4's he came up to my knee so it appears most of them got the HUGE gene. He was the only neighborhood tom so I knew he was all the kittens daddy. Biter and Goldie had the previous neighborhood tom average size tabby(he looked exactly like Nuts) whose reign had ended when he was run over by a car as their dad.
I know all of them have the same father since we only had one neighborhood tom at the time. Not sure if they were different ages but they all appeared to be the same age when the moms brought all 9 of them over at 4 weeks old. 4 cats gave us 15 kittens, I honestly wanted to shoot myself and we got the moms done as soon as the low cost s/n clinic could get them in, by then Mama was in heat and Goldie was around 2 weeks pregnant and Biter wasn't either.
So yes it is possible. All of mine were with mom and grandma until at least 12 weeks(Attitude and Nuts) the other 3 are still with mom and grandma, were never ever tortured by anyone and there is still a big difference, Half-tail is the only one who won't get on the roof of our house or the neighbor's(at 8 weeks old I found Attitude on the neighbor's roof with 4 of her siblings sleeping in the gutters) and has never climbed a tree, when I go outside I see at least one cat climb out of a tree to come see me. You can have a big difference, Attitude can get on the counter from the floor, Nuts has to use something to get on the counter(and only Attitude is allowed on the counter, it's her safe place to escape from Nuts when he won't give up trying to bite the 'Tude and her hissing and growling and swatting won't deter him, stupid cat.)
Taryn